BestReviews is reader-supported and may earn an affiliate commission. Details
Expert Shopper
Beyond reviews, our team aims to provide you with useful, compelling, and fun how-to guides, gift ideas, and deep dives into trendy products consumers like you love. Here are our latest articles.

Halloween Squishmallows and other stuffed toys your kids will love

If your kid is just as obsessed with Halloween as they are with soft toys, they'll love Halloween Squishmallows. These extra-plush, squidgy stuffed toys are fun for imaginative play, make comfy pillows and are just nice to hug. 

However, it's not just Squishmallows that makes adorable Halloween-themed soft toys. You can find plenty of other Halloween plushies that your child will adore.  

In this article: Squishmallows "Nightmare Before Christmas" Jack SkellingtonSquishmallows Tally the Cat Vampire and TeeTurtle The Original Reversible Big Spider Plushie

What are Halloween Squishmallows?

To understand what Halloween Squishmallows are, you must first learn about Squishmallows. First released in 2017 by Kellytoy, Squishmallows are super soft and squishy plush toys with rounded shapes, a little like marshmallows. Squishmallows all have names and come with tags describing their personalities, which is part of what makes them so popular and collectible. 

Halloween Squishmallows are simply Squishmallows with a Halloween twist. You can find a wide range of cute characters from mummy owls and vampire cats to ghosts and witch's brews. 

What to look for in Halloween Squishmallows

If you're set on buying a Halloween Squishmallow toy, you should know what to look for. The characters given to each toy makes them stand out, plus you can find versions of beloved characters in the company's special lines. Also pay attention to the size of each toy since it varies widely. 

  • Character: Every Squishmallow has its own unique character given to it by the manufacturers. On the tag that comes on every toy, you'll find the name of the toy and information about its personality. It might seem like a small touch, but this is part of what many kids find exciting about these toys. Squishmallows makes a number of Halloween-themed toys, including cats, bats and ghosts, all with an adorable spin.
  • Size: You can find Squishmallows in a range of sizes, from tiny 3.5-inch key fob plushies to extra-large 24-inch versions. However, the majority of Halloween plushies measure 8 to 10 inches. 
  • Special lines: Squishmallows makes some special Halloween-related lines of toys. For instance, it has partnered with Disney to bring out ranges of toys based on "Hocus Pocus" and "The Nightmare Before Christmas." These adorable takes on existing characters are popular with fans of the movies in question. 

Other Halloween soft toys for fans of Squishmallows

If your kids love soft toys but aren't completely obsessed with Squishmallows, they might be happy to receive other Halloween soft toys. If they like the shape and softness of Squishmallows, look out for other similar varieties. If they're happy with any soft toy that has a Halloween theme, you have even more options. 

Halloween soft toys range from completely cute to slightly spooky, so think about your child's preferences when buying. If they're likely to be creeped out by a spooky plush, opt for something on the cuter end of the spectrum. 

Popular Halloween soft toys include black cats, pumpkins and jack-o-lanterns, bats and ghosts. You can even find reversible Halloween plushies, which are popular with many kids.

Best Halloween Squishmallows and other soft toys

Squishmallows "Nightmare Before Christmas" Jack Skellington

This 8-inch Jack Skellington is an adorably chunky version of the Pumpkin King that any fan of "The Nightmare Before Christmas" is sure to cherish. It is officially licensed by Disney and offers excellent attention to detail, such as Jack's iconic bat bow tie.

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows "Nightmare Before Christmas" Sally

Continuing on the "Nightmare Before Christmas" theme, this adorable plushie is modeled after Sally. It measures 8 inches tall and is finished beautifully, so any fans of Jack and Sally's love story will want to have them both.

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows "Nightmare Before Christmas" Mayor

Thanks to its double-sided design, this toy gives the Mayor of Halloween Town two faces with distinct expressions. It's nicely detailed with the character's tall hat on a squat body typical of Squishmallow toys.

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows Calio Black Cat with Witch Hat

Cats don't always have to be the familiar — sometimes they can be the witch. In her adorable purple witch's hat, Calio the cat is perfect for Halloween and is a new design for 2022.

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows Tally the Cat Vampire

Not only can cats be witches, they can be vampires, and cute ones at that. Kids will love Tally the Cat Vampire, who sports a classic Dracula-style vampire costume that includes a cape. 

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows Official Halloween Soft Plushes

You can choose from a range of Kellytoy Halloween plushies in this listing, ranging in size from mini 3.5-inch key fobs to large 12-inch options. Toys on offer include Emily the bat, Ellette the vampire owl and Regina the corgi in a spider costume.

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows Felize the Ghost

Far more cute than spooky, this adorable ghost plushie has a smile on its face, blushing cheeks and a striped hat. It's 10 inches tall and extremely soft and squishy. 

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows Johanna the Witches Brew 

New for 2022, Johanna is the cutest witch's brew you've ever laid your eyes on. At 10 inches tall, this toy is a good size for kids and is exceptionally huggable.

Sold by Amazon

Squishmallows Winston the Mummy Owl

All wrapped up in bandages, Winston the owl might have been mummified, but he certainly isn't scary. Kids will love how soft and squishy this 8-inch plush toy is.

Sold by Amazon

Pillow Pets Disney Zero Stuffed Animal

Large and super soft, this 16-inch plushie is part stuffed toy and part pillow. It's modeled after Zero, Jack Skellington's ghost dog from "The Nightmare Before Christmas," and perfect for kids to snuggle up with or take on trips.

Sold by Amazon

Chudatom Halloween Cow Stuffed Animal

If your child is a fan of the soft and squishiness of Squishmallows and their chunky shape, they're bound to love this cow plush toy. Its skull and cobweb design gives it a spooky Halloween edge.

Sold by Amazon

TeeTurtle The Original Reversible Big Spider Plushie 

Kids can turn this plushie inside out to transform it from a big, hairy spider into a jack-o-lantern. You can also choose from other Halloween designs, including reversible ghosts and cyclops.

Sold by Amazon


Want to shop the best products at the best prices? Check out Daily Deals from BestReviews. 

Sign up here to receive the BestReviews weekly newsletter for useful advice on new products and noteworthy deals. 

Lauren Corona writes for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their purchasing decisions, saving them time and money.

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers.

Share this post: