Buying guide for best cast iron dumbbell sets
Ready to buy now? Shop the best:
For many of us, cardio, aerobics, stretching, and eating right are all part of our fitness regimen, but for one reason or another, lifting weights hasn't made it into our routine yet. If you want to get in the best shape of your life, weights need to be part of the plan, and a cast iron dumbbell set is the easiest way to incorporate that element.
If you've never lifted weights before, figuring out which kind to get might be a bit overwhelming. To help you find the best cast iron dumbbell set to suit your needs, we researched 30 different options. In the end, the Yes4All Old School Adjustable Dumbbell Set and the FitRx SmartBell XL 90-Pound Adjustable Dumbbell Set made it to the top of our list for their durability, comfort and ease of use.
Editors' picks
Yes4All Old School Adjustable Dumbbell Set
Editors’ Favorite
Weight range: 40 to 200 lb | Dumbbell Type: Adjustable | Handle Material: Textured chrome
Whether you are a beginner or advanced weight lifter, the Yes4All Old School Adjustable Dumbbell Set is one of the best cast iron dumbbells sets for all fitness levels. It features two dumbbells with eight weight plates that can be adjusted in different configurations. The set is available in a wide selection of weight choices to fit various workout needs.
The bars that come with this set are both rugged and stable. Made of chrome with a textured finish to prevent slipping, they’re comfortable to grip and hold during long weight-lifting sessions.
We also appreciate how simple it is to change the weight plates and keep them secure. The set includes star-lock collars that fasten to the bars to keep the plates from moving during workouts. When it’s time to remove or add plates, the collars are easy to take on and off the bars.
FitRx SmartBell XL 90-Pound Adjustable Dumbbell Set
Great Value
Weight range: 10 to 90 lb | Dumbbell Type: Adjustable | Handle Material: Rubber coated
If you’re looking for one of the best cast-iron dumbbells in terms of affordability and versatility, the FitRx SmartBell XL 90-Pound Adjustable Dumbbell Set is an outstanding choice. Although it’s available at an appealing price, it features a wide range of weights that are easy to adjust to accommodate different workout needs.
In addition to a bar that’s rubber-coated for a stable grip, this set comes with weights ranging from 10 to 90 pounds. An excellent option for all skill levels, the weights can be adjusted in 17 different configurations for customized fitness routines and includes a quick-adjust dial for speedy changes.
We also love that this set is simple to store. The bar and weights fit nicely into the included storage rack, so it won’t take up much space in your workout area or home gym.
BalanceFrom Rubber Coated Hex Dumbbell Weight Set
Best for Beginners
Weight range: 5 to 50 lb | Dumbbell Type: Fixed weight | Handle Material: Neoprene-coated cast iron
If you’re looking for classic dumbbells for minor to moderate workouts, the BalanceFrom Rubber-Coated Hex Dumbbell Weight Set is one of the best cast iron dumbbell sets to consider. It features 50 pounds total in color-coded pairs of 5-, 8- and 12-pound weights for versatility when working out.
This well-designed set has important features that add safety to your workout. The dumbbells are hexagon-shaped so they won’t roll when placed on flat surfaces, and the contoured handles make them easy to grip and hold.
We also like that these dumbbells are coated in neoprene — a synthetic rubber material that makes them soft to the touch and slip-resistant to use. The material wipes clean with a damp cloth and soap.
This set won’t take up a lot of space in your home gym. The dumbbells come with a rack with slots for storing each pair. The rack is easy to assemble and has a rugged handle so you can move it from place to place with minimal effort.
Key considerations
A dumbbell is basically a bar that is equally weighted at each end to provide balance. Before you start looking at details such as shape and coating, however, there are two main features you need to consider first: fixed or adjustable and the total weight.
Fixed vs. adjustable
Fixed weight: Purchasing a set of cast iron dumbbells with fixed weights means you’ll have a separate pair of dumbbells for each weight. For instance, one pair of dumbbells may weigh 5 pounds while another weighs 10 pounds. These dumbbells are typically one piece, so they’re durable, and you can quickly increase or decrease weight just by picking up a different pair. The downside to fixed-weight dumbbells is that they take up more room.
Adjustable weight: For adjustable dumbbell sets, you typically get two bars, four collars, and a variety of weight plates. No matter how easy it is to add or remove plates, it will never be as fast as simply picking up a fixed weight dumbbell in the middle of a workout. You must also be certain to fully tighten the plates onto the bars whenever you’re adding or removing weights to be sure they’re secure during your workout. The big advantage to having adjustable weights is they take up considerably less room to store.
Expert tip
I always recommend purchasing a dumbbell stand to prevent clutter in your home gym because a stand makes storing and quickly selecting weights much easier.
BestReviews Fitness Expert
Total weight
The other key consideration is the total weight of the set. For a fixed-weight set, this means the weight of the largest dumbbell, because you can only hold one at a time in each hand. For an adjustable set, it means the number of plates you can fit on one bar. You don't want to purchase a set of cast iron dumbbells that’s too light to be of any use. You also don’t want a set that’s so heavy you could injure yourself. One thing you need to watch out for is that adjustable sets usually list the weight of the entire set. If you purchase a 50-pound set, for example, that means 25 pounds on each bar.
Cast iron dumbbell set features
After you’ve considered the main points, you can focus on the details that can enhance the user experience.
Shape
Cast iron dumbbells come in many shapes. Disk-shaped plates are the norm in adjustable sets, but fixed weights can be round, square, or hexagonal. The main benefit to square and hexagonal weights is that they’ll stay in place when you set them down.
Coating
Cast iron is prone to rust and corrosion, so most weight sets are coated.
Paint: Painted sets are the most affordable, and they can be repainted if the coating starts to chip.
Chrome: Chrome-coated sets look more impressive, but when they chip, it's much harder to repair.
Soft: Soft coatings such as rubber or neoprene will help with grip and protect both your dumbbells and floor from damage, but those coatings are typically only found on fixed-weight sets. Additionally, the coating is often colored to make it easy to quickly identify the weight you want to grab. On the downside, these coatings can also wear away, and on some of the less-expensive brands they may actually begin to deteriorate or melt and damage your floor or furniture.
Expert tip
Although rubber or vinyl-coated weights are designed to help prevent damaging floors, I don't recommend dropping the weights on the floor after performing your last repetition since this can still cause damage.
BestReviews Fitness Expert
Grip
A textured grip is best, especially once you begin sweating. The main area of concern is that textured bars can have a few stray shards of metal, which can deliver painful splinters. It's best to wipe these bars down and be careful during the first few workouts to lessen the chance of injury.
Storage
Some sets come with a stand, while others may come with a case or tray. If the set you’re considering doesn’t include any means of storage, you might want to consider purchasing something separately to help keep your cast iron dumbbells better organized.
Cast iron dumbbell set prices
When considering the price of a cast iron dumbbell set, in general, the more weights there are in the set or the heavier those weights are, the more the set costs.
Inexpensive
A set of two dumbbells weighing a couple pounds each costs less than $10. For under $50, you can find a lighter-weight set of three or four pairs of colored neoprene-coated, fixed-weight dumbbells. The heaviest weight will be 10 pounds or less. Some of these lower-priced sets include a stand.
Mid-range
In the $50 to $100 price range, you can find adjustable sets of cast iron dumbbells featuring two handles, four collars, and a variety of weight plates that total less than 100 pounds.
Expensive
Spend more than $100, and you'll find mostly the same materials as in the lower-priced sets, but these sets have more or heavier weight plates.
Tips
- Consult your doctor before you exercise. Before starting any kind of exercise routine, it’s best to get the approval of your doctor. Weight training, in particular, can put a great deal of stress and strain on your body, so you want to be certain it’s safe for you before beginning.
- Do some dynamic stretches before lifting. Stretching while moving improves your mobility through the range of motion and helps prepare you for strenuous activity.
- Use proper form. Always execute exercises with proper form. If you can’t, it means that the dumbbells you’re using are too heavy.
- Pay attention. If something hurts or doesn't feel right, stop. No pain. Period. Pain is your body's way of telling you something is wrong. Listen to it.
- Pace yourself. You need to be able to finish your entire workout routine. Burning out in the first five minutes won't help you. In fact, it could cause you to perform movements in a sloppy manner, which can lead to injuries.
- Recover between workouts. Fitness happens in two stages: tear it down and build it back up. If you do hard workouts seven days a week, your muscles won’t have a chance to recover.
- Stretch again. After working out, it’s advantageous to perform some static stretches. These will help prevent fatigue and lessen any muscle soreness.
Expert tip
Dumbbells offer a lot of variety when designing strength training programs compared to barbells. I always recommend starting with dumbbells first to work on the stabilizer muscle and then progress to adding barbell exercises to your program.
BestReviews Fitness Expert
FAQ
Q. What are the benefits of weight training?
A. If you’re doing a cardio-heavy workout and think that you don’t need weight training, you're wrong. Cardio, at best, is only half of the equation. When you add weights to your exercise routine (in the right way), you’ll experience such obvious benefits as increased strength and better ability to handle day-to-day tasks. Weight training also burns calories, strengthens connective tissue, and can even increase bone density, which can reduce the risk of osteoporosis.
Q. I don't want to bulk up. Are weights really for me?
A. Yes! Lifting weights alone, even heavy weights, isn’t going to turn you into a bulked-up beast. The type of fuel you put into your body plays a critical role in how big you get. Additionally, if you don’t wish to add bulk, focus on exercising your slow-twitch muscles, the muscles that provide endurance.
Q. What weight should I start with?
A. Although many guides offer a set rule like starting with a certain weight, that isn’t the best approach. As with any physical endeavor, you need to pay attention to your body. You want to start with a weight that’s heavy enough to make you feel it after ten repetitions but not so heavy that you have to strain, shake, or lose form. If that happens, you need to use a lighter weight. By the end of your third set (with only 30 to 60 seconds of rest between sets), you should be struggling to finish, but it’s still important to not break form or jerk the weights in order to complete that last rep. If it’s too easy to do three sets of ten, you can gradually increase the weight until you discover your ideal.
