Large cooking surface works for pancakes, sushi and more. Well-suited for both grilling and broiling. Reversible. Pre-seasoning is an added bonus.
Difficult to clean and move when hot.
Heats evenly and its heavy construction makes it easy to use once broken in. It is flat-bottomed so it will not move on the burner - unlike others.
Will rust after a few washes if not properly seasoned. Loop is not much of a handle.
An affordable model by a top name in cast iron griddles that offers similar user-friendly features as pricier options - pre-seasoning and reversible cook surfaces. Versatile, mid-level size.
Edge "walls" aren't wide enough to prevent oil from spilling off the sides. A few reports of uneven griddles that seemed warped.
Stands our for its spacious surface that makes it handy for preparing large volumes of food. Pre-seasoned and reversible.
Heavier than most, which is both a testament to it's craftsmanship and feature that makes it awkward for some to use. On the higher end of the price scale.
A large, spacious iron griddle that's pre-seasoned and reversible. Has ample-sized edges to catch grease. Comes at slightly lower price point than others in its class.
Several owners gripe that it doesn't cook evenly - gets hotter in the middle than around the edges. Food occasionally sticks.
We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.
Imagine how long it would take to get served if the short order cooks at the diner did everything in pans instead of on a griddle. You’d be waiting for an hour instead of 10 minutes for your meal. Short order cooks know how to cook for a crowd: on a griddle. When you’re tasked with making pancakes for a gaggle of kids or frying up a dozen hamburger patties for a rained-out cookout, you should follow their lead.
Home griddles have been around for years, and for a good reason: they work. In fact, the more you use an iron griddle, the better it works. You simply set your griddle over a burner or two, and you have a cooktop to rival the Waffle House. Although griddles remain fundamentally simple and unchanged, there is still a lot to consider when purchasing one. Which griddle would best suit your culinary needs? That’s where we come in.
At BestReviews, we give our honest opinions on a number of products, including iron griddles. We take no free samples from manufacturers; everything we test is bought by our team right off the store shelf. For a brief overview of some of our favorite iron griddles, take a look at the matrix above. For a deeper dive into the realm of cheffing like a short order cook, read on.
Size matters – especially when you’re cooking something like pancakes, the quintessential griddle food, for a fairly large group of people. Griddles, particularly the larger ones that fit over two burners, give you more room to work with, so people get fed faster.
Plus, since most griddles are basically flat (unlike skillets), there’s no edge to impede the chef from flipping, scattering, or maneuvering like a true maestro.
What’s more, the sloped sides of a skillet hold in moist air. Without those edges, a griddle gets a better crust on food made from watery or moisture-rich ingredients. Think of crispy, golden-brown hash browns and the aforementioned pancakes.
A griddle cake is different from a pancake in that it contains a raising agent, commonly baking powder.
When most cooks think of griddles, they picture cast iron – and for good reason. Cast iron, once warmed up, retains heat better than almost any other material. This is great if you’re looking to cook something fast on a super-hot surface.
Conversely, it’s also perfect for dishes that require consistent heat, like hamburger patties.
The biggest drawback to using a cast iron griddle is the cooldown time. The griddle gets so hot and releases heat so slowly that if you’re not careful, cleaning up could be a finger-charring experience.
Before the advent of steel, people often made griddles from stone tablets and brick slabs. In parts of Latin America, people cook on a budare, a griddle made of clay or stone. Nowadays, most commercial griddles - like the one you might find at your local breakfast joint - are made from A36 steel.
Griddles made from anodized aluminum heat up quickly and maintain consistent heat fairly well. They’re lighter than their cast iron counterparts, but they’re also much less durable. They can warp over time, which makes it difficult for the griddle to sit flat on the cooktop.
Anodized aluminum has the advantage of being nonstick, but the coating can flake or peel off if you’re too rough when cleaning the surface.
Basic nonstick aluminum griddles have one major selling point: price. But they’re less expensive for a reason. They’re much thinner and lighter than even anodized aluminum griddles, but they don’t typically retain heat as well.
Uneven cooking is a common problem with nonstick aluminum products, and they’re notorious for warping. Griddles made with cast aluminum tend to be more durable, but they still tend to cook unevenly. The same goes for ceramic griddles.
Some foods cooked on a griddle need to be finished in the oven, so you might consider buying a griddle with an oven-proof handle.
The last thing a cook wants is a griddle that won’t stay put. Choosing one with a heavy, flat bottom will keep it from sliding off the burners at inopportune times, like when you’re flipping a pancake … or when you accidently bump the stove.
While aluminum griddles need only to be washed, cast iron griddles require much more care and patience; you can’t just soap it up in the sink and set it out to dry.
For tip-top performance, cast iron needs to be seasoned regularly – any time it looks dull or muddled. This means baking oil into the cast iron to prevent rusting. See our “How to Season a Cast Iron Griddle” section for more details.
You can use your oven-safe cast iron griddle as a pizza stone. You’ll get a perfectly crisp crust every time.
Cast iron is heavy; there’s no getting around it. A cast iron griddle can be a pain to move around the kitchen, from the cabinet to the stovetop, from the stovetop to the sink, and back to the cabinet again. But they’re also basically indestructible; many are passed down from generation to generation as a sort of family heirloom.
However, if you’re not the strongest person, or if you have smallish hands, you might want to consider another material. Anodized aluminum griddles feel sturdy despite their lightweight construction, so one of those might be a good option.
Don’t underestimate the value of good griddle handles. You’re probably going to be moving your griddle around a lot, and strong, comfortable handles will make it much easier. Cast iron handles are certainly tough, but they also stay hot for a long time. Metal handles aren’t as sturdy and have the same problem with retaining heat.
Some griddles offer heat-resistant handles in the shape of loops. While these won’t burn your fingers, they might not be hardy enough to easily move the heavy griddle around your cookspace.
Griddles are great for campfire cooking. In fact, they can be used with almost any heat source.
Like nearly every other kitchen tool, griddles have been “upgraded” in recent years with unique features, and some of them are quite useful.
Some griddles now feature deep grease wells which keep the grease away from the food but, more importantly, away from the burner where it could become a fire hazard.
Another handy advancement is the addition of a pour spout on some models, making getting rid of excess cooking liquid both safer and easier.
These add-ons might not make you a better cook, but they’re worth looking into if you’re concerned about safety.
Using too much oil can cause your griddle to smoke excessively. Drain the extra oil off before you start cooking.
There are several ways to season cast iron, but one of the most common methods starts with pouring a small amount of vegetable oil onto the griddle.
Next, use a clean cloth or paper towel to spread the oil all over the griddle, front and back.
Place the griddle in the oven upside down and bake it on medium heat (about 350°F) for around an hour. You might want to put a piece of aluminum foil on a rack under the griddle to catch any excess oil that drips off.
When the hour is up, turn off the oven, but leave the griddle in there to cool down slowly.
Q. Are there any foods that I shouldn’t cook on a cast iron griddle?
A. Like a cast iron skillet, you can cook anything on a cast iron griddle as long as it’s properly seasoned. A cast iron griddle that lacks seasoning should not be used to cook highly acidic foods (tomatoes, for example). The acid can strip the oils from the cast iron and change the color of the griddle and the taste of the food being cooked.
Q. Are cast iron griddles nonstick?
A. The more you use and season your cast iron, the less food will stick to it. Having said that, a cast iron griddle will never be as nonstick as a pan made from something like Teflon. A well-used cast iron griddle should have little trouble letting go of whatever you are cooking.
Q. How do I prevent hot spots, which lead to uneven cooking, from developing on my griddle?
A. The answer lies in preheating. When you preheat your griddle, you allow the heat to spread throughout the material and “even out” across the surface. Making sure that your griddle is well-seasoned helps, too.
At BestReviews, we purchase every product we review with our own funds. We never accept anything from product manufacturers. Our goal is to be 100% objective in our analysis, and we do not want to run the risk of being swayed by products provided at no cost.