Facebook Pixel Code
 

Best Train Sets

Updated October 2018
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers.
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
How we decided

We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

  • 16 Models Considered
  • 1 Experts Interviewed
  • 142 Consumers Consulted
  • Zero products received from manufacturers.

    We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

    Why trust BestReviews?
    BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.
    BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers.
    BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.

    Shopping guide for the best train sets

    Last Updated October 2018

    Imagine a brand new train set circling and puffing around the tree on Christmas morning. Exciting, indeed! In fact, a train set is one of the coolest nostalgic toys you’ll find on the market any time of year. A train set entices the imagination. For some, it inspires an exciting hobby that includes building cars, collecting accessories, and arranging tracks on long and winding journeys.

    But because there are so many train sets on the market, it may be hard to figure out which would be best for you. That’s where we come in!

    At BestReviews, our goal is to provide our readers with honest, unbiased reviews of the best products available. Our five favorite train sets are listed in the product matrix above. If you’d like to learn more about train sets and how to choose one for yourself or a loved one, please continue reading this shopping guide.

    If you wish to enhance a collector’s experience or a child’s imagination with a new train set, look for cars with lots of interior detail. Box and freight cars have unique characteristics, but ultimately, they have little interior detail and are shaped like boxes. Passenger cars and dining cars are designed with details like seats and tables to bring a sense of reality to the toy.

    Model trains vs. toy trains

    The first thing you should know as you embark on your shopping journey is that two types of trains exist: model trains and toy trains. There is a bit of overlap between the two, but the design and function of each is unique. Here are some standout characteristics of model and toy trains.

    Model trains

    • Model trains are miniature copies of real-life trains. Accuracy is a major focus.
    • Model trains are usually built to scale to look as much like real trains as possible.
    • Model trains are favored by collectors and historical train lovers.

    Toy trains

    • Toy trains are often built from cheaper materials, but because they’re meant to be played with, they tend to be more durable than model trains.
    • Toy trains are not as realistic as model trains, but they retain a basic resemblance.
    • Wooden trains and toddler pull-toys fall under this category, as do products like the Thomas and Friends line.

    Age ranges

    Both model and toy trains are designed for fun, but the type of fun is different. To get an idea whether a train set is designed for collection or play, take a look at the manufacturer’s prescribed age range. For example, you'll find some themed train sets that are suitable for children age eight and up. You'll find some toy-like train sets that should only be used by kids age 14 and up due to certain features, such as "real smoke" and delicate detailing.

    CAUTION

    Some model trains include tiny breakable parts that could pose a choking hazard for younger kids.

    Engines

    At the front of every train is the engine. Just like real life, this is where the train gets its energy. Some engines run on battery power; others must be plugged into the wall.

    Battery-powered engines

    Battery-operated engines have a small compartment underneath where you load the batteries. To turn them on and off, you must manipulate a switch on the engine.

    Electrically powered engines

    Electrically powered engines run on an electric current in the track itself. The current is harmless and only activates when the metal of the engine’s wheels touches the metal of the rails. You activate them from a transformer box with a switch that plugs into a wall socket or with a remote control.

    A remote-controlled train operates using the same principles as an RC car. You can control the speed of the train going both forward and backward. You also have the ability to blow the whistle and make other sound effects.

    Cars

    A train just isn’t a train without a full complement of cars trailing behind it. Each set comes with at least two specific types of cars, and it’s possible to purchase additional cars beyond what’s in the box. Here’s a brief list of car types you’ll encounter in the world of trains.

    • Coal car: This car is designed to look like it has a full load of coal to fuel the burner.
    • Gondola: This is an open-top storage car. It usually comes with plastic or wooden logs to give the appearance of wood storage.
    • Box car: This is a side-opening container designed to carry food or livestock.
    • Quadhopper: This car is designed like a gondola but made to carry coal.
    • Passenger/dining car: The most common structural design in this category features two rows of passenger seats with an aisle down the middle. Some have an “Orient Express” design with private cabins. The dining car usually features a single drinking bar and eating tables along the floor.
    • Tank car: This is a long, black, cylindrical car used to transport oil and other liquids.
    • Freight car: This is a side-opening container holding cargo and bigger luggage.
    • Off-center caboose: In real life, the caboose was traditionally used as a place for the train’s staff to sleep and for the storage of broken or used equipment.

    A box car with a ventilated top is designed to carry livestock.

    Car materials

    Once upon a time, most train sets were made of metal in order to accurately exude the look of a real train. Nowadays, plastic is the preferred material. It’s cheaper to manufacture, and it makes the trains lighter and the parts easier to replace. However, you can still find some trains that are made at least partially of die-cast metal.

    Tracks

    The most common track designs are a circle or an oval. This simplicity allows you to easily set up the train straight out of the box.

    Tracks are generally plastic, but the rails are made from one of four materials: brass, steel, zinc-coated steel, and nickel silver. Brass conducts electricity the best and is the most common.

    Each track connects to the next using a T-slot formation. One piece will have two rods that stick out and fit into the T-shaped slots of the next piece. When track pieces are connected, the metal track aligns perfectly so the train runs smoothly without falling off or bumping into an off-center rail.

    DID YOU KNOW?

    Quadhoppers and gondolas come in various designs, but only a gondola has movable parts that can be placed in or around the car. A quadhopper, much like a coal car, has a plastic mold of “decorative” coal that’s cemented inside the car itself.

    Track types

    • Straight track: This is the name given to a piece of track that forms a straight line.
    • Curved track: This is a piece of track that bends to form a curve, giving you the option to sway the train’s path in various directions.
    • Switches/crossings: These pieces are designed to integrate roads as scenery. They also serve as a point where you can change travel directions by flipping a switch.
    • Split track: Shaped like a Y, this is a piece that connects to a nearby switch track so you can control/alter the direction of the train.
    • Flex track: Made from flexible plastic and metal, these pieces can accommodate bumps in terrain much easier than straight track can.
    • Bridges: These pieces are designed to lift the train over rivers, gullies, and other deep areas. Some designs include plastic supports.

    Other components

    Earlier we mentioned Thomas & Friends, the beloved TV show about Thomas the train and his buddies. Indeed, this TV show (as well as the books that preceded it) have inspired many folks to get into train play and train collecting.

    Who could forget the lush scenery and stations that Thomas and his friends would visit? Much like that beloved story, you can add accessories and other components to your train set to create a lush environment.

    Below is a list of common items you could purchase to enhance your train set:

    • Scenery: This includes trees, shrubbery, fake bodies of water, hills, and other pieces of land.
    • Train stations: A play “train station” is a neat spot for a train to stop and take a rest.
    • Signals and signs: This includes authentic-looking railroad crossing and stop signs.
    • Lights: Some trains come with brown powerlines to feed the lampposts that light their way.
    • Buildings and figures: This includes construction workers, station attendants, conductors, passengers, and, of course, buildings.
    • Tunnels: Some mountains can’t be scaled; you must tunnel through them. What fun!

    Track pieces generally snap together and hold themselves firmly in place, but they’re also designed to pull apart easily.

    Terms

    The world of model trains has a lot of its own terminology. These words describe what different parts are and how they function. The list of terms is expansive, but here are some of the most common.

    • Cab: This is the cabin where the conductor handles the engine.
    • Backdrop: This scenic picture is used to create an image of the train in a specific location.
    • Combine: This is a passenger car that serves more than one purpose, such as holding postal bags and carrying passengers.
    • Fine scale: In this type of train design, modelers tighten up the standard designs to be even more accurate.
    • Coupler: This term refers to the hardware used to join trains and cars together.
    • Kitbash: This is a practice in which designers alter parts of a set to create a unique car or structure.
    • Points: These are the movable rails of a turnout or switch.
    • Scale: This refers to the ratio of the size of a model train to the size of a real-life train.
    EXPERT TIP

    You can purchase additional tracks to expand your collection. The more tracks you own, the more different paths your train can take.


    Scott  | Do-It-Yourself Guru And Carpenter
    EXPERT TIP

    If your train set runs on battery power, check them before play to make sure they're still working. Train sets that sit on a shelf for an extended period may lose battery power.


    Scott  | Do-It-Yourself Guru And Carpenter
    EXPERT TIP

    Many train sets have some liquid smoke loaded, but they may not come with a refill bottle. You have to buy it separately once the smoke runs out.


    Scott  | Do-It-Yourself Guru And Carpenter

    Train scales

    Each train set falls under a specific design lettering which primarily defines its size but is also used to classify the purpose of the set. These three happen to be the ones most frequently used by manufacturers.

    • HO scale: This is the most commonly used scale. By definition, it’s a reduction in size (the scale per inch compared to a real train) of 1:87.1.
    • O scale: The O scale employs a reduction size of 1:48. 
    • G scale: The G scale has a reduction size of 1:22.5, but more importantly, the design is suited to being outdoors and withstanding the elements.

    Attention to detail

    Die-hard train collectors tend to pay attention to fine details. It’s one thing to say your model looks kind of like the Union Pacific engine; it’s another to say your model looks precisely like the Union Pacific.

    If you’re interested in trains with realistic details, there are some areas you should check to make sure what you’re purchasing looks, sounds, and acts like the genuine article. For example, you might want to pay close attention to the following.

    • The sounds of the car, bell, whistle, and wheels
    • The amount of smoke that comes out of engines with a smokestack
    • The headlights (do they work?) as well as the caution lights on the side
    • Logos and decals from companies operating at the time of service
    • The paint scheme, branding, and numbering on the train
    • The shape and design of the cow catcher

    It’s possible to glue track pieces together. However, without solvent, you wouldn’t be able to reconfigure the tracks later.

    Setting up

    Most train sets are fairly easy to set up straight out of the box. Here’s a summary of the general guidelines offered by most manufacturers.

    • Unpack everything.
    • Lay down the track in the design you wish. Keep in mind that the tracks need to connect from start to finish.
    • Load the batteries (if needed) into the engine.
    • Connect the power box or transformer to the track as indicated. Keep the switch in the “off” position as you plug it in.
    • Place the engine on the track first. Then, connect the remaining cars in the order you wish them to follow.
    • Turn on your train and play.

    Train set prices

    Price is one of the hardest things to gauge when it comes to a train set because companies put different values on different aspects.

    However, we can apply a general segmentation of the pricing into 2 sections — around $75 and around $100.

    Around $75

    You'll find some great choices for kids in this price range, including character sets and trains that emit "real" smoke and/or run with the help of a remote control.

    Around $100

    You'll find more detail-oriented train sets in this price range. You're also more likely to find train sets from highly respected manufacturers here. Keep in mind that it may be easier to buy additional pieces and accessories down the line if your original train set hails from a well-known maker.

    Once upon a time, every major city was connected by the railway. For an exciting life-like display, have your train pull into a town populated by buildings and figures.

    FAQ

    Q. How can I change the shape of my track?

    A. The easy answer is to experiment and get creative. But if you don’t quite know where to start, there are dozens of online guides that can show you different shapes to make with what you have.

    Q. My train set has plastic rods. What are these?

    A. These accessories are called track clips. They’re an optional addition that helps ensure the tracks don’t slip apart after frequent use.

    Q. Can I mix and match train sets?

    A. Only if they’re from the same company. Train manufacturers don’t generally allow you to mix and match brands. Your particular model probably wouldn’t work with a different brand.

    Q. How can I get mountains and other massive pieces of scenery?

    A. You can either purchase pre-made models from a hobby store or research online DIY guides that will show you how to make them.

    The team that worked on this review
    • Devangana
      Devangana
      Web Producer
    • Melissa
      Melissa
      Senior Editor

    BestReviews wants to be better. Please take our 3-minute survey,
    and give us feedback about your visit today.

    Take Survey