Best Plush Dog Toys

Customer Favorite

Featuring a wide range of designs, Knotties are far stronger than they look, and will survive its fair share of tugs, fetches, and snuggles.

2 layers of strongly sewn fabric, and 5 squeakers. Tightly knotted arms and legs for rough playtimes. Soft corduroy exterior. Available in 2 other animals as well as both large and small sizes.

Cozie Elmer the Elephant Dog Toy

Not intended for strong chewers.

Best Bang for the Buck

Kong

Durable Yet Cute

As durable as it is cute, an extra layer of material helps to make this fuzzy elephant last longer for extra value.

Strong construction, and it includes a squeaker. Extra soft and snuggly toy for small to medium sized breeds. 2 size options to be easy to play with for puppies and smaller breeds.

Dinos Chew Guard Frills Triceratops Dog Toy

Best for cuddles, not for hardcore chewers.

GoDog

Sensory Fun

These rugged yet soft dinosaurs are cuddly, crinkly, squeaky, and a perfect fit for all but the biggest dog breeds.

Chew Guard technology makes this a tougher plush toy. Several other dinosaurs to pick from, available in large or small. Soft, makes crinkle noises, and includes a squeaker.

Not intended for chewing, and not 100% indestructible.

Jolly Pets

Tug-a-Mals Crab Dog Toy

Indoor Plush Toy

A surprisingly soft yet durable plush toy for indoor tug-of-war fun for dogs of all sizes.

Braided nylon crab legs will withstand many a fetch. This is a super-tough squeaky ball covered in plush and cuddly fur. Available in small, medium, or large.

Remember that it’s a tug-toy, not an indestructible chew toy.

Hyper Pet

Wildlife Critter Dog Toy

Most Versatile

These super-fuzzy and soft wildlife toys are an excellent consolation prize if your dog is still fuming over the squirrel they’ll never catch.

Remarkably realistic design, ultra-plush fur and soft design. Meets child toy safety standards, so a good pick for homes with small children. A great size for all dogs. 5 different animals to choose from.