Best Mousetraps

Updated November 2020
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
Updated November 2020
Written by Melissa Nott Authors 's image

Buying guide for best mousetraps

Unwelcome guests have invaded your home, and you’ve decided to set a mousetrap.

But what kind should you get? How should you bait it? And what will happen once the animal is trapped?

To help you make an informed purchase, we discuss these issues in our mousetrap buying guide.

We're dedicated to writing the most honest and unbiased reviews out there. We do not accept products directly from manufacturers; we use our own funds to purchase the same “off-the-shelf” products that you do.

And when we've finished our testing and consumer reviews, we donate all these products to charities and other non-profit organizations.

Our ultimate goal: to become your go-to source for trustworthy product recommendations whenever you’re faced with a buying decision.

At the top of this page, you'll find our five favorite mousetraps on the market. These highly rated products all qualify for our top-contender list.

Avoid ultra-cheap snap traps if you’re not completely comfortable with the extermination process. Some pricier models feature wind-up spring mechanisms for a “no see ‘um” dispatch, while others allow you to step on a special hinge to set the trap — no fingers necessary.

Common types of mousetraps

The spring-loaded "snap trap"

The cheapest mousetrap is also one of the most common: the snap trap. Snap traps are generally sold in multiples and designed to be disposable. A wooden or plastic base contains a simple spring-loaded device with a bit of bait on one end and a thin metal bar on the other. The bar is held under considerable tension by a centralized spring and a trip wire connected to the bait holder.

Lured by the bait, the mouse crosses the trip wire and the bar snaps shut. This action either breaks the mouse’s neck/spine or pins it down until the user can dispose of the entire trap.

    "The cheapest, most common mouse trap is the snap trap."
    STAFF
    BestReviews

    Pros:

    • Affordable
    • Sold in multiples
    • Fits in small, hard-to-reach areas
    • Easily disposable

    Cons:

    • May be unsafe to have around pets and small children
    • Occasional false positives (trap sets itself off)
    • May be difficult to retrieve from hard-to-reach areas
    • Painful demise for animal
    • Gruesome clean-up

    The glue trap

    Another inexpensive method of exterminating mice is the glue trap. A glue trap is a piece of wood or cardboard that is liberally coated with sticky resin and placed in various locations around the home, including pest entry and exit points.

    The mouse steps onto the glue trap, which may or may not be baited, and becomes mired in the heavy adhesive. Death is not instantaneous, but owners can dispose of the entire trap without making contact with the animal.

      "Look for glue traps that don’t skimp on the amount or quality of adhesive. Cheap glue traps with only a thin coating are better for catching insects than rodents."
      STAFF
      BestReviews

      Pros:

      • Safer for homes with pets and/or small children
      • Rodent death is less gruesome than snap trap
      • Also traps invasive insects (silverfish, spiders, ants, cockroaches)

      Cons:

      • Can be messy
      • Resin is difficult to remove from skin and clothing
      Did you know?
      Chemical or ultrasonic repellents may also help encourage mice to leave on their own.
      STAFF
      BestReviews

      The live trap

      Some people have moral or ethical objections to killing animals. For these folks, a live trap is more appealing.

      A live trap is essentially a cage with a collapsible door. When the mouse enters the live trap, the door closes, prohibiting escape. The user then takes the entire cage to a release area and sets the mouse free. This type of trap costs more than some other options, but it can be used again and again.

      "If catching and releasing mice with a live trap is your goal, be sure to buy a trap rated for small rodents."
      STAFF
      BestReviews

      Pros:

      • A more ethical choice for some people
      • Owner has option of relocating the animal without harming it
      • Can be used repeatedly

      Cons:

      • Expensive
      • Cost may be prohibitive if infestation is large
      • User must find a place to release the animal
      Did you know?
      Some live traps are too large for mice, and their triggering mechanisms are not sensitive enough to detect their presence.
      STAFF
      BestReviews

      The electronic trap

      Some people don’t mind killing mice, but they have concerns about the methodology used. Snap and glue traps don’t always deliver an instant death blow, resulting in excessive suffering for the animal. For these people, an electronic trap is a more desirable solution.

      Attracted to a protein-based bait such as bacon or peanut butter, the mouse enters the trap via a tube. Inside, the creature trips an electrical circuit and receives a powerful shock that dispatches it instantly. The user can then dispose of the remains (without contact), bait the trap again, and reset the unit’s electrical circuit.

      "Don’t be fooled by advertising hype when it comes to electronic mousetraps. Battery-powered models can deliver the same jolt as a stun gun, but actual results vary. Invest in a higher-end model that uses both house current and a battery backup."
      STAFF
      BestReviews

      Pros:

      • Some people consider the high-voltage jolt a more humane form of extermination
      • User can dispose of remains without any direct contact
      • No need to reset the trap manually
      • No moving parts that pose a threat to pets or children

      Cons:

      • Expensive
      • Cheap electronic traps may not deliver a lethal jolt

      The bait decision

      Few mousetraps work without some form of bait. Protein-based foods work well, but some choices are more effective than others.

      Cheese

      Many people assume that cheese is the ideal enticement, but research suggests that mice aren’t always attracted to traps baited with cheese. One theory is that people tend to handle the cheese too much during the baiting process, and mice can detect human odors very easily. Whatever food you choose to use, it’s important to handle the bait as little as possible when preparing your mousetrap.

      Peanut butter

      Peanut butter is one of the hottest mousetrap baits right now. Why? Mice are naturally attracted to nuts and seeds, and the scent of peanut butter suggests both protein and fat to a hungry mouse. Bird seed is also used by some people.

      Bacon

      Fatty bacon, or even small chunks of jerky, are commonly used in mousetraps with great results. Mice are carnivores, after all.

      Other foods

      If you don’t have any of the above solutions on hand, consider baiting your trap with a bit of oatmeal, cracker, butter, chocolate, or pet food.

      With glue traps, the pest will be mired in the heavy adhesive, but not killed instantaneously.

      Other baiting tips

      • Avoid using “too much” bait. The smaller the amount, the closer the mouse must come to the trap.
      • Chemical attractants can also be used to boost the power of organic baits.
      • Switching between several different kinds of bait can improve your results, as mice eventually become “nose blind” to the same scent every day.
      • Some traps work equally well with or without bait. Because mice have poor vision, they prefer to travel along walls; trap placement is key.
      • Some commercial trap manufacturers claim that their product is “pre-baited,” but the effectiveness of these products is questionable.
      Other Products We Considered
      The BestReviews editorial team researches hundreds of products based on consumer reviews, brand quality, and value. We then choose a shorter list for in-depth research and testing before finalizing our top picks. These are the products we considered that ultimately didn't make our top 5.
      See more

      BestReviews wants to be better. Please take our 3-minute survey,
      and give us feedback about your visit today.

      Take Survey

      Our Top Picks