Best Hammer Handles

Tapered replacement hammer handle that's available in multiple lengths for convenience.

Handle is a high quality American hickory, which both looks great and performs well, especially considering the price. Has a sharp-looking quality of grain in the handle. Contains all of the pieces you need to attach the head to the new handle. Available in lengths between 10 and 16 inches. Made for hammers from 8 to 12 ounces, so it's versatile.

Oval Eye Engineer's Or Blacksmith Hammer Handle

Some problems with build quality and shipping quality on a few models.

Best Bang for the Buck

Seymour

Great price for a big replacement hammer handle that is made for really large hammer heads.

Handle measures 16 inches in length, so this replacement piece is made to fit really big hammer heads. Consists of American hickory wood with a durable finish on it, which means it will continue to look good over time. Ships with both metal and wood wedges, allowing you to pick the style that will work best for your hammer head.

Hatchet Replacement Handle

Will not fit smaller or average sized hammer heads.

Vaughan

Solid build and heavy hammer replacement handle that will work well with bigger hammer heads.

Large hammer handle at 17.5 inches and with 10 ounces of weight, so this model is made for big hammer heads. Ships with both metal and wood wedges so you can pick the best option for your needs. Wood material in the handle is of a high quality that should give you a nice level of performance over time.

16" Ball Peen Hammer Handle

A little pricey. Manufacturer doesn't specify the type of wood in use.

Seymour

High-quality replacement handle that's made to tightly fit big and heavy hammer heads.

Handle that consists of hickory wood that will give you an excellent level of performance with amazing looks over time. Grain of the wood looks especially good. Really nice price point for a hammer handle of this quality. Handle measures 16 inches in length, so it works best for bigger hammer heads.

18" Curved Replacement Handle

May take a bit of sanding and some other adjustments to make the handle fit properly.

Stiletto

It's pricey, but the curvature of this hammer handle is not commonly found with replacements.

Handle measures 18 inches in length, so you'll be looking to add this handle to a big hammer head. Ships with both metal and wood wedges, allowing you to pick the material that will work best with your needs. Curvature of this handle will help you maintain a steady grip on the hammer.