5 Best Cat Toy Gift Sets - Apr. 2023

Updated January 2023

Why trust BestReviews?

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more

Bottom line

Pros

Cons

Includes a variety of 14 toys plus a textured brush that are sure to please any cat.

Pros

Including an array of toys such as jingle bell balls, catnip-filled plush fish, pop-up cube, and Mylar balls, this gift set is packaged in a box that can be repurposed as a scratching post, catnip container, or just a place for cats to sit.

Cons

Smaller toys may not hold up to cats who like to play rough.

Best Bang for the Buck

Zanies

Moppy Mice Canister Set

Check Price

Most Pieces

Bottom Line

A pack of 42 mice will keep cats and kittens entertained for the long haul.

Pros

Providing a large quantity of mice, cats can chew up or lose mice and you’ll have more to give them. Mice come in 3 different colors and have a built-in rattle to entice cats to play with them more.

Cons

Some buyers found the mice tails to be torn or chewed off quickly and advised keeping an eye on cats for choking hazards.

SmartyKat

Birthday Bash Catnip Variety Pack

Check Price

Best Catnip Toy

Bottom Line

This set of 16 cat toys includes catnip filled mice that your feline friends will love.

Pros

Ribbons, feathers, plush toys and more are sure to entertain your cat and keep them happy. Featuring a birthday theme, with toys in the shape of cake and candles, this makes a great gift for any cat.

Cons

Some shoppers found their cats got bored with toys and wished for more variety in this set.

Including a wide variety, this set features smaller toys that are just the right size for kittens.

Pros

This set has it all; feathers, crinkly balls, catnip, mice and more. Interactive toys, like the fishing wand stick, allow you to play with your cat or give them toys to play on their own. A great set of toys to encourage cats to stay healthy and active.

Cons

While great for kittens, larger cats may tear toys apart more easily.

Cat Is Good

2-Piece Pounce Toy Gift Box

Check Price

Most Stylish

Bottom Line

A nice presentation box makes this toy set a perfect gift for a cat lover.

Pros

The 12 assorted toys come nicely packaged in a box for gifting. Includes some feather toys and others with catnip. Soft toys in the set are well-made and easy for cats to bat around during play.

Cons

Sparkle balls with metallic-looking threads could easily be pulled out and ingested; watch cats during play.

HOW WE TESTED

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

Click here for testing insights

Models
Considered

135

Consumers
Consulted

Hours
Researched

Cats like to get gifts too, especially when they receive a collection of their favorite toys. Cat toy gift sets make excellent gifts for felines, as well as their owners because they are packed with toys that crinkle, jingle, or just entice cats to play. Some sets include toys that have been made with catnip and gadgets like play wands that are designed for interactive playtime. Sets are also available in gift-worthy boxes that are ready to give. Think about the kitty that will be playing with his new toys before you buy, because cats that participate in exuberant or rough play require toys made of materials that aren't easily destroyed.

Our Top Picks