Header Image
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
HOW WE TESTED

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

30
Models
Considered
60
Consumers
Consulted
26
Hours
Researched
Category cover

Buying guide for Best Christmas throw pillow covers

Christmas throw pillow covers can add an extra dimension to your festive decoration. Why stick to decorating your tree and mantle when you can get your couch in on the action? With so many options available, finding the best festive throw pillow covers can be a challenge.

For most buyers, the design and background color or print are the main event, so these are features you should spend some time deciding on. However, you should also consider the size and shape of any throw pillow covers you're considering and how easy they are to wash and care for.

Once you know more about what to look for in a festive throw pillow and you've cast your eye on some recommended options, making your purchase will be much simpler. Soon you'll have your Christmas throw pillow covers sorted, and you can get on with enjoying the festive fun.

Christmas throw pillow covers
If you have a color palette for your Christmas decorations, consider sticking with this theme for your festive throw pillows.

How to buy the best Christmas throw pillow covers

Festive designs

You can find all kinds of festive designs on Christmas throw pillow covers, so there's an option to suit most people's decorative tastes and preferences. There's everything from traditional Christmas scenes with vintage-style illustrations of Santa or snowy log cabins to highly contemporary designs that are sleek and stylized. If you're trying to bring some Christmas magic into your home for kids to enjoy, you might prefer more cartoonish designs, or you could forgo pictures or illustrations altogether with festive typographical designs. This comes down to personal preference, so you may need to browse for a while to find a design you love.

Background color

In addition to the design, consider the background color of the throw pillow cover. The color makes a huge difference in the overall appearance of the pillow, so pick carefully. You can choose to match or contrast your couch or to select a color that works with your other festive decorations. You may wish to buy a festive pillow in a traditionally Christmassy hue, such as red, green, or gold. In addition to solid colors, you can find some festive pillows with patterns or prints behind the main design, such as plaid or stripes.

Size

Think about what size pillows you'd prefer. If you have existing pillow inserts you want to use, this will dictate the size of Christmas throw pillow covers you should buy. Otherwise, go with your preference. The most common pillow size is 18 by 18 inches, so the vast majority of Christmas throw pillow covers come in this size. However, you can find some smaller and larger options if you shop around.

Shape

Most festive throw pillow covers come in a standard square shape. This is because buyers are more likely to already have square pillow inserts they can use. If you were to buy the whole pillow with the insert included, it would be easier to experiment with other shapes. That said, you can find some Christmas throw pillow covers in less common shapes, including rectangular cushions and round cushions. While you'll definitely need a rectangular pillow insert to fit in a rectangular pillow cover, you can often manage to squeeze a square cushion into a round pillow cover.

After eleven months of storage, pillow throw covers may become creased. To address this, we suggest looking for ironable Christmas throw pillow covers.

STAFF
BestReviews

What features do Christmas throw pillow covers have?

Closure

Throw pillow covers can have a range of closure types, including zipper closures, envelope closures, and drawstring closures. Zipper closures completely secure the insert inside the cover and are often hidden so they're not obvious and won't dig into you. However, since it takes time and effort to sew in a zipper, this can add a dollar or two onto the price. Envelope closures consist of two pieces of fabric on the back of the pillow that slightly overlap, so you can slip the insert inside. This type of closure is often found on cheap cushions but is less secure than a zipper closure. Some pillows have buttons or ties added to keep the pillow insert more secure. Drawstring closures aren't common on throw pillows, but they aren't unheard of. They feature a drawstring at one end to securely keep the insert in the cover, but they aren't the neatest of solutions.

Washability

Ideally, your chosen throw pillow covers should be machine washable. You won't be using your Christmas throw pillow covers for more than a month or two throughout the year, so they shouldn't get excessively dirty, but it's still nice if they're easy to wash. This will save you time and energy if something gets spilled on one of your pillow covers or if you want to wash them before storing them for next Christmas.

Embellishments

Some festive throw pillows have embellishments, such as sequins or pompoms. These can add to the appearance of a pillow but shouldn't make them less functional. For example, when a pillow is so covered in sequins that it's uncomfortable to lean on, it isn't much use as a pillow, even if it looks great.

Christmas throw pillow covers
DID YOU KNOW?
You can purchase personalized Christmas throw pillow covers embroidered with names, special dates, or anything else significant, but they can take a while to arrive, especially in the weeks prior to Christmas.
STAFF
BestReviews

How do you accessorize a Christmas throw pillow cover?

Pillow inserts

In an ideal world, you'd already have some throw pillows onto which you could temporarily place Christmas pillow covers. However, you might find you don't have enough, they're the wrong sizes, or they look excessively worn when you remove the covers. In this case, you'd need to find suitable pillow inserts. For the plumpest and most comfortable pillows, choose polyester hollow fill or faux down inserts that are a couple of inches bigger than the cover.

Festive throw blankets

If Christmas throw pillow covers aren't enough to complete the festive look on your couch, you could also get festive throw blankets. You might be able to find a throw blanket with a similar design or color scheme to your throw pillow.

How much do Christmas throw pillow covers cost?

Inexpensive

You can find inexpensive Christmas throw pillow covers for less than $5 each when you buy them in a set.

Mid-range

Mid-range Christmas pillow covers cost $5 to $15 each, depending on the quality and whether they're sold in sets or individually.

Expensive

The priciest festive throw pillow covers cost from $15 to $30 apiece. These are luxury pillow covers that are sold individually.

Many consumers think it practical to buy Christmas throw pillow covers rather than Christmas pillows with inserts. In this situation, everyday pillow inserts can be used, and there is less to store when January comes.

STAFF
BestReviews

Tips

  • Choose a design you'll be happy to use year after year. To get your money's worth, you'll probably want to use your festive pillow covers for many Christmases to come. Therefore, choose a design that you'd be happy to use again and again. Avoid anything that's too on-trend that might go out of style in a year or two.
  • Consider the color palette in your living room. Consider choosing Christmas throw pillow covers that match or complement the existing color palette in your living room, den, or wherever else you intend to put your pillows.
  • Think about whether you want individual pillow covers or a set. You can buy Christmas throw pillow covers either individually or in sets. If you like the matching look, it's best to choose sets of pillows with designs that are slightly different but with the same color scheme. However, those who prefer a mismatched look may prefer individual throw pillow covers.
Christmas throw pillow covers
Consider your personal style when choosing Christmas throw pillow covers. They don't have to be to anyone's taste but your own.

FAQ

Q. Do pillow covers need to be bigger than the pillow?

A. No, throw pillow covers don't need to be bigger than the pillow insert because pillows can be compressed into spaces smaller than their relaxed dimensions. In fact, we'd recommend choosing a pillow insert that's 2 inches larger than the pillow cover — a 20-inch insert for an 18-inch throw pillow cover, for example. This makes pillows look plump rather than disappointingly flat.

Q. How do you dry throw pillow covers?

A. Check the label inside your chosen festive throw pillow covers to find the washing and drying instructions. In many cases, it's better to air dry them, but if you must tumble dry them, do so on low with the cover turned inside out so the design is on the inside. Make sure your pillow covers are completely dry before storing them for next Christmas. Otherwise, they may be musty or moldy by next December.

Q. Is it worth buying Christmas throw pillow covers?

A. You might be wondering if it's worth buying Christmas throw pillow covers if you'll only use them for a month or so each year. This comes down to personal preference, so there's no right or wrong answer. However, if you like the idea of festive throw pillows but want to get more use out of them, you could choose pillow covers with a subtle winter theme that you could use throughout the whole season. For instance, you could choose pillow covers with a snowflake design, red and black buffalo check, a stag print, or a snowy scene.

 

Other Products We Considered
The BestReviews editorial team researches hundreds of products based on consumer reviews, brand quality, and value. We then choose a shorter list for in-depth research and testing before finalizing our top picks. These are the products we considered that ultimately didn't make our top 5.
Our Top Picks