Best Mister Rogers Toys

Updated October 2020
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
Best of the Best
Funko POP! TV: Mr. Rogers Collectible Figure
Funko
POP! TV: Mr. Rogers Collectible Figure
Check Price
Customer Favorite
Bottom Line

These collectible Mister Rogers dolls will appeal to adults and children alike, and will appreciate in value.

Pros

Three 0.75-inch tall dolls, packaged for collectors. Other Mister Rogers' Neighborhood characters also available. Funko Pop dolls often increase in value over time.

Cons

Quality issues with paint and construction. Box may arrive in less than collectible condition.

Best Bang for the Buck
The Unemployed Philosophers Guild Hello Neighbor - Mister Rogers Magnetic Dress Up Play Set
The Unemployed Philosophers Guild
Hello Neighbor - Mister Rogers Magnetic Dress Up Play Set
Check Price
Most Stylish
Bottom Line

For nostalgic viewers of the original Mister Rogers series, this magnetic set of interchangeable clothing and props has great appeal.

Pros

Set contains numerous magnetic costume pieces. Works well as refrigerator art. Hundreds of possible mix-and-match combinations. Also includes puppet characters and neighborhood trolley.

Cons

Does not contain as many pieces as some expected. Price point is relatively high.

Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood Friends & Family Figure Set (10 pack)
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Friends & Family Figure Set (10 pack)
Check Price
Best for Kids
Bottom Line

This versatile set of figurines is ideal for younger viewers of the Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood successor series.

Pros

Figures are 2.5 inches tall, with pose-able arms and movable heads. Complete set of characters, including exclusive Pandy. Suitable for ages 3 and up. Promotes creative play for a single child or a group.

Cons

Some manufacturing defects reported. Individual pieces are lightweight, may not stand upright.

Holgate Classic Trolley
Holgate
Classic Trolley
Check Price
Simple Yet Solid
Bottom Line

Parents and grandparents who grew up watching Mister Rogers will like having this realistic trolley model as a conversational piece.

Pros

Significant collection value. Produced by authorized "Neighborhood Trolley" company. Includes popular puppet characters and a blank tile for customization. Constructed from hand-painted wood.

Cons

Wheels may not fit standard track pieces. Some assembly defects noted, including uneven wheels and cracked wood.

Briarpatch Daniel Tiger's Welcome to Mainstreet
Briarpatch
Daniel Tiger's Welcome to Mainstreet
Check Price
Best for Beginners
Bottom Line

Young fans of the Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood series will enjoy the opportunity to engage with classic characters from the Mister Rogers era.

Pros

Game play encourages basic counting and interactivity. Designed for 2 to 4 players ages 2 to 6. Includes many popular puppet characters from Land of Make Believe.

Cons

Contains many small parts, not safe for toddlers. Game play may be too advanced for younger kids.

How we decided

We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

51 Models Considered
8 Hours Researched
2 Experts Interviewed
196 Consumers Consulted
Zero products received from manufacturers.

We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

Mister Rogers' Neighborhood was a groundbreaking children's television series that featured an amiable, low-key host named Fred Rogers. The show combined live action sequences with visits to an imaginary land populated by both humans and puppets. For decades, Mister Rogers addressed important issues for children, such as divorce, bullying, and growing up in a direct but compassionate way. Many viewers of public television have fond memories of watching Mister Rogers at school or at home.

The Mister Rogers show, and its successor Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood, has spawned a number of educational toys and other materials. We have created a shortlist of toys inspired by the series, and we believe they will appeal to both adults and children who have fond memories of both shows.

Other Products We Considered
The BestReviews editorial team researches hundreds of products based on consumer reviews, brand quality, and value. We then choose a shorter list for in-depth research and testing before finalizing our top picks. These are the products we considered that ultimately didn't make our top 5.
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Daniel Tiger Mini Plush
Fred Rogers
Mister Rogers Talking Figurine and Paperback
Aquarius
Mr. Rogers Gen 2 Fun Box
Aquarius
Mr. Rogers Playing Cards
Funko
Pop! Movies: A Beautiful Day in The Neighborhood
Funko
POP! Keychain: TV Mr Rogers Collectible Figure
Funko
SuperCute Plush: Mr. Rogers Neighborhood
Funko
Mr. Rogers Vinyl Figure Bundled with Pop Box case
Aquarius
Mr Rogers 500pc Puzzle
Funko
Mister Rogers with Puppet Exclusive
Buffalo Games
Mister Roger’s Neighborhood - Jigsaw Puzzle
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Trolley with Daniel Tiger Figure, Single
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Electronic Trolley Vehicle , Daniel & Mom Tiger
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Friends Figures Set
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Friends Plush
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Snuggle and Glow Plush Toy
Amscan
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood Party Game
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Potty Time Toy
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Tigey Mini Plush Basic Plush Toy
Hallmark
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood Ornament
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Cute and Cuddly Baby Margaret Plush
Daniel Tigers Neighborhood
Talking Baby Margaret Plush, 12 inch
Daniel Tigers Neighborhood
Bath Time Daniel Tiger Figure
Baby Bath Tub Toy Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Bathtub Voyage Adventure, 6 Piece Set
Daniel Tigers Neighborhood
Trolley with Daniel Tiger Figure & Friends Figures
Daniel Tigers Neighborhood
Friend Katerina Kittycat Plush
Daniel Tigers Neighborhood
O The Owl Mini Plush
Daniel Tigers Neighborhood
Katerina Kittycat Mini Plush
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Musical Instruments 7 Piece Play Set
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Tiger and Katerina Kittycat Figures
See more
×

Funko

POP! TV: Mr. Rogers Collectible Figure

Funko

POP! TV: Mr. Rogers Collectible Figure

These collectible Mister Rogers dolls will appeal to adults and children alike, and will appreciate in value.
$10
×

Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood

Friends & Family Figure Set (10 pack)

Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood

Friends & Family Figure Set (10 pack)

This versatile set of figurines is ideal for younger viewers of the Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood successor series.
$19
×

The Unemployed Philosophers Guild

Hello Neighbor - Mister Rogers Magnetic Dress Up Play Set

The Unemployed Philosophers Guild

Hello Neighbor - Mister Rogers Magnetic Dress Up Play Set

For nostalgic viewers of the original Mister Rogers series, this magnetic set of interchangeable clothing and props has great appeal.
$14
×

Holgate

Classic Trolley

Holgate

Classic Trolley

Parents and grandparents who grew up watching Mister Rogers will like having this realistic trolley model as a conversational piece.
$92
×

Briarpatch

Daniel Tiger's Welcome to Mainstreet

Briarpatch

Daniel Tiger's Welcome to Mainstreet

Young fans of the Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood series will enjoy the opportunity to engage with classic characters from the Mister Rogers era.
$15

BestReviews wants to be better. Please take our 3-minute survey,
and give us feedback about your visit today.

Take Survey

Our Top Picks
Funko POP! TV: Mr. Rogers Collectible Figure
Best of the Best
Funko
POP! TV: Mr. Rogers Collectible Figure
Shop Now
The Unemployed Philosophers Guild Hello Neighbor - Mister Rogers Magnetic Dress Up Play Set
Best Bang for the Buck
The Unemployed Philosophers Guild
Hello Neighbor - Mister Rogers Magnetic Dress Up Play Set
Shop Now
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood Friends & Family Figure Set (10 pack)
Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood
Friends & Family Figure Set (10 pack)
Shop Now
Holgate Classic Trolley
Holgate
Classic Trolley
Shop Now
Briarpatch Daniel Tiger's Welcome to Mainstreet
Briarpatch
Daniel Tiger's Welcome to Mainstreet
Shop Now