Best Cat Mice Toys

Customer Favorite

Twelve little fuzzy cat mice toys that are quite appealing to most felines.

Soft and adorable mice toys that are covered in faux fur with 3 colors per pack. Cats are attracted to the rattling noise they make during play. Collection includes 12 mice.

Cattraction Silver Vine & Catnip Cat Toys

Chemical-like smell may be a deal-breaker for some pet owners. Reports of the mice breaking open and the rattle beads falling out.

Best Bang for the Buck

Hartz

Cat-Attracting Mice

Colorful mice toys that cats can't resist thanks to a combination of silver vine and catnip.

These cat mice toys stand out for being infused with both silver vine and catnip– 2 safe and natural stimulants that entice most cats to play. Twelve mice per pack in several fun colors.

Tails are easily bitten off, especially by cats that are extremely excited by silver vine or catnip.

A large collection of cat mice toys that's perfect for multi-cat homes or felines that frequently indulge in play.

A generous pack of 36 toy mice in a variety of bright colors. Mice rattle, which is a feature most cats love. Made with soft, fuzzy synthetic fur.

Play-N-Squeak Mouse Hunter Cat Toy

Some reports of beads falling out. While most cats love these toys, some aren't enthused by them.

OurPets

Most Realistic

This fun interactive toy promotes active play with catnip and realistic noises and appearance.

Made for interactive play, as this catnip-coated toy makes mouse-like noises when cats play with it. Looks realistic, and brings out felines' instinct to hunt.

Skitter Critters Catnip Toy Mice

A few defective mice didn't make noise. Some concerns about longevity noted.

SmartyKat

Lightweight & Soft

Choose these cute mice toys for cats that prefer to play with catnip over rattling toys.

Soft, plush mice toys that are easy for cats to bat around and don't contain hard pieces. Infused with natural catnip that felines love. Pack of 10 mice in gray and tan colors.