PETA-certified cruelty-free make-up. You’ll get long-lasting natural wear, thanks to how well it intensifies eye pigments. Creates flawless and smoother makeup by minimizing creasing. Makes your colors shine. Also, it makes your preferred shade a 100 times vivid.
Since it is cream-based, it often takes some time to dry.
This versatile, natural-looking formula earns praise for looking excellent by itself for most and for bonding with eye makeup for reliable coverage and wear. Pigments reflect light. Provides a soft satin finish that is slightly pearlized. Offers anti-aging benefits.
Shade requires effort to blend on darker skin. May settle into lines and crease.
Also works as a brightener for the eyelids. Corrects discoloration and provides all-day wear by itself or with other makeup. Stays in place even in hot, humid conditions. Crease-proof.
Dries quickly. Expensive. Applicator doesn't reach product at the bottom on tube.
Works on all skin tones. Color stay technology keeps makeup on and looking freshly applied for up to 24 hours. Shea butter care complex will give you a soft and smooth foundation. You’ll get a non-drying and non-greasy effect when you apply it.
While it stays on all day, it often starts to crease after a few hours.
Formula does a good job keeping eyeshadow in place without creasing. Pretty, neutral shade can also be worn by itself. A little goes a long way. Ideal for evening wear.
Takes a little effort to blend onto eyelids, as the consistency is somewhat thick.
We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.
No matter how much experience you have applying makeup, you’ve likely dealt with faded, dull eyeshadow from time to time. Even if you use a quality primer, some shadows just don’t seem to look as bold as you’d like. Enter the eyeshadow base, which can keep your eye makeup looking vibrant and flawless from morning to night.
An eyeshadow base is similar to an eyeshadow primer: you blend it into your eyelids before applying your eyeshadow. It has a slightly tacky texture, which helps it grab onto the eyeshadow to intensify the color. Bases are available in various colors too, helping to boost the pigmentation of the shadow. Their stickiness can also help eyeshadow last longer than it does on bare lids.
The terms “eyeshadow base” and “eyeshadow primer” are often used interchangeably, but there are some key differences between the two products that are important to understand.
Eyeshadow bases usually have a thicker, creamier texture that’s slightly tacky or sticky. That allows it to grab hold of the eyeshadow you apply on top of it and intensify its color. Eyeshadow bases often come in nude or skin-tone shades, which can help cancel out any discoloration in your eyelids (such as redness) that might affect the way an eyeshadow looks. You can also find eyeshadow bases in other colors, so you can match the base to the eyeshadow color you’re using or choose a color that brightens or deepens the shadow.
Eyeshadow primers typically have a thinner consistency that isn’t particularly sticky. It helps create a smooth, even canvas on which to apply your eyeshadow. It also prevents the oils in your eyelids from seeping through and causing the shadow to crease and fade. Eyeshadow primer is usually translucent, though some have a slight tint.
Most eyeshadow bases have a cream formula, so they work incredibly well if you have dry, textured eyelids. You can usually apply these bases with a clean finger or a synthetic makeup brush.
Some eyeshadow bases are slightly thinner, with an almost liquid consistency. These usually come with some type of applicator built into the lid.
You can even find a few powder eyeshadow bases, which is an excellent option if you have oily eyelids.
Eyeshadow bases are available in a few different finishes. Many are matte and don’t have any shine when applied to the skin. These are a good choice for oily eyelids. However, you can also find some eyeshadow bases with a shimmery finish, which attracts light to give your eyes a slight glow.
In most cases, an eyeshadow base’s finish isn’t that important because the eyeshadow you apply over it may have a different finish. However, if you plan to wear the base on its own to even out your eyelids or add a soft wash of color to your eyes, think more carefully about the type of finish you prefer.
Because most eyeshadow bases have a thick, creamy formula, they typically come in small pots or compacts. You dip a finger or brush in the container to get some of the product and apply it to your eyelids.
Thin, liquid eyeshadow bases generally come in a tube, like a concealer or lip gloss, with a wand built into the cap for application. These enable you to apply the base without getting any product on your fingers.
Powder eyeshadow bases usually come in a small jar or pot. Some brands have a locking sifter, which prevents the powder from going everywhere if you accidentally knock it over.
Skin tone: All eyeshadow bases are tinted to provide at least some color to your lids. Many are nude or skin tone to help even out any discoloration in your lids. You don’t need to match the color to your skin exactly but look for an option that’s as close as you can get to your natural coloring. These bases are ideal if you don’t want the base to change the color of your eyeshadow too much.
White and black: Many brands also offer white and black eyeshadow bases. A white eyeshadow base is an excellent option if you want to make your eyeshadow color appear brighter and more vibrant without changing the color much. A black eyeshadow base deepens the color of a shadow and is also highly effective at bringing out the different tones in duochrome eyeshadows.
Other colors: You can also find an eyeshadow base in nearly any color under the sun. Matching the base to your eyeshadow color can increase the pigmentation and make your shadow look more vibrant. For example, you might pair a purple eyeshadow base with a lilac shadow to achieve a more intense look.
While the primary purpose of an eyeshadow base is to intensify the color of the eyeshadow rather than prolong its wear time, some bases can help your shadow last longer than others. Creamier, more emollient bases don’t last as long, while thinner formulas can often last all day.
If you have dry eyelids, creasing and fading likely aren’t a problem, so you can opt for a creamy base. For oily lids, you’ll want to stick to a thinner formula for a longer wear time.
Eyeshadow primer: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eyeshadow Primer
If you want to be sure your eye makeup lasts all day, you definitely want to apply an eyeshadow primer before your eyeshadow base. This one from Elizabeth Mott is a standout because its lightweight formula dries quickly to allow you to apply your eye makeup quickly and easily. It’s also paraben-free.
Eyeshadow bases vary in price based on the formula, ingredients, wear time, and other factors. Most bases cost between $5 and $50.
Inexpensive: The most affordable eyeshadow bases are from drugstore makeup brands and include lower-quality ingredients. They’re typically cream formulas that come in small pots or compacts. Most are available in fairly basic shades like white, black, and nude. You’ll generally pay between $5 and $12 for these eyeshadow bases.
Mid-range: These eyeshadow bases are typically from high-end makeup brands and feature average- to high-quality ingredients. They are available in cream, liquid, and powder formulas and come in basic shades as well as more vibrant colors. You’ll pay between $14 and $26 for these eyeshadow bases.
Expensive: The most expensive eyeshadow bases are from luxury makeup brands and include the highest-quality ingredients. They’re available in cream or liquid formulas and come in both basic and vibrant shades. You’ll typically pay between $26 and $50 for these eyeshadow bases.
A. Since they ultimately serve different purposes and have different textures, you can use an eyeshadow primer and an eyeshadow base together. It’s important to use them in the correct order, though. Primer usually has a thinner texture and is designed to keep the oils in your eyelids from breaking down your eyeshadow, so it should be applied first. You can then layer a tinted or colored base over the primer to help it stay in place all day.
However, you don’t have to use eyeshadow primer and base together. You can wear the primer under your eyeshadow without a base to help improve its wear time, or you can opt to apply an eyeshadow base and layer eyeshadow over it to intensify the color.
A. It depends on how you use your base and the type of makeup looks you prefer. A basic nude-colored base can work with and help intensify eyeshadow of any color, so it might be all you need.
However, if you prefer a more dramatic look, you might also want a white and/or black base for certain eye looks. If you experiment with a wide range of eye looks, you might even want a few eyeshadow bases in specific colors, such as purple or pink.
A. Like any makeup product, an eyeshadow base can expire. Because you apply it to your eyes, you should be especially careful about not using a base that might contain bacteria. You can usually use a base for a year or two before it expires. If you notice any changes in its scent or texture, it’s time to toss it.