Menu
 

BestReviews is reader-supported and may earn an affiliate commission. Details

Best Gas Fireplaces

Updated March 2024
Bottom line
Pros
Cons
Best of the Best
Darby Home Co. 44" Ventless Fireplace
Darby Home Co.
44" Ventless Fireplace
Check Price
Customer Favorite
Bottom Line

This is a stylish freestanding ventless gas fireplace that comes in a choice of finishes and includes logs.

Pros

Attractive freestanding design with an option of finishes to fit your decor. Heats up to 26,000 BTUs for effective warmth for spaces as large as 1,350 square feet. Adjustable thermostat. Logs have a realistic appearance.

Cons

Some customers didn't receive the remote. A few griped about damage during shipping.

Best Bang for the Buck
ProCom 32.25" Ventless Stove
ProCom
32.25" Ventless Stove
Check Price
Simple Yet Solid
Bottom Line

An affordable freestanding ventless model that has a cozy appearance and does a good job heating small to mid-size areas.

Pros

Delivers 25,000 BTUs of power that can produce warmth for rooms up to 1,100 square feet in size. Vent-free and straightforward to assemble. Thermostat is adjustable to achieve the perfect temperature. Logs included.

Cons

Rare reports of heater defects and damage during transit.

Pleasant Hearth Ventless Fireplace
Pleasant Hearth
Ventless Fireplace
Check Price
Feature-packed
Bottom Line

This is another ventless gas fireplace with logs that has appealing looks and produces reliable warmth.

Pros

Freestanding model with logs and heat output up to 33,000 BTUs. Effectively heats spaces as large as 1,100 square feet. Not overly challenging to assemble. Vent-free. Adjustable thermostat.

Cons

Comes with a subpar remote that is prone to malfunctioning.

Duluth Forge 27.62" Fireplace Insert
Duluth Forge
27.62" Fireplace Insert
Check Price
Ideal for Large Rooms
Bottom Line

Ventless installation, good looks, and nice heat output earn this realistic gas fireplace a top spot on our list.

Pros

Earns praise from owners for looking like a real fireplace. Ventless model with logs and an adjustable thermostat. Delivers 32,000 BTUs that can heat rooms up to 1,500 square feet in size. Attractive screen and brick insert.

Cons

A few fireplaces had damaged components upon delivery. Reports of remotes that quit working.

Pleasant Hearth 36" Convertible Vent-Free Dual Fuel Fireplace in Heritage Oak
Pleasant Hearth
36" Convertible Vent-Free Dual Fuel Fireplace
Check Price
Budget-friendly
Bottom Line

An attractive gas fireplace with a price that's slightly lower than others on our list, earning it our home improvement expert's recommendation.

Pros

With 22,000 BTUs, a versatile 36-inch design, and a beautiful finish, you may be surprised that this option comes at a slightly lower price than many others in its class.

Cons

Rare issues with the burner and igniter.

Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. About BestReviews  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. About BestReviews  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.About BestReviews 
HOW WE TESTED

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

35
Models
Considered
131
Consumers
Consulted
8
Hours
Researched
Category cover

Best gas fireplaces

Modern living has its luxuries, and one of them is the gas fireplace. Yes, you could split wood, lug it inside, and ignite a fire in your living room fireplace if you wanted to – but you don’t have to. With a gas fireplace in your home, you can relax in the warmth of a roaring fire with the simple press of a button.

If you’re shopping for a gas fireplace, you’ll find lots of reliable models on the market. Some sit right inside your regular fireplace; others are made to stand alone. At BestReviews, we studied the products in order determine which are the very best gas fireplaces. In the product list above, you’ll find our favorites.

If you’d like to learn more about gas fireplaces in general, please read on to discover facts, tips, and the answers to common questions you may have. When it comes to an appliance like this, it’s important to make an informed purchase. At BestReviews, we’ve got you covered.

Content Image
If you want to breathe life into an older traditional fireplace but don’t want to pay for a major home renovation, consider a gas fireplace insert.

Types of gas fireplaces

One of the first decisions you need to make is whether you want a gas fireplace installed from scratch or one that you can insert into an existing wood-burning fireplace.

Freestanding

A freestanding gas fireplace can go wherever you want it to go. You don’t need to have an existing fireplace or chimney. Some freestanding gas fireplaces (called “vented” gas fireplaces) exhaust their fumes through a hole in your wall. Others are ventless; the exhaust enters your indoor space.

Keep in mind that ventless units are banned in some municipalities and states. They may require permits for installation. You'll want to research the codes in your area before choosing a gas fireplace.

Expert tip
Have your gas fireplace inspected annually by a professional to ensure no cracks are in the logs or fuel lines that can lead to gas leaks.
BestReviews Home Improvement and DIY Expert

Insert

A gas fireplace insert goes right into your existing fireplace. It includes one or more burners and artificial logs. Some inserts are encased in a metal box. Others are simple log/burner sets that you attach to a gas line. Inserts are available in vented and ventless configurations.

Vented or ventless: which is right for your home?

You can choose a freestanding gas fireplace or gas fireplace insert that is either vented or ventless, but what’s the difference? That’s an important question to answer before you make your purchase.

Ventless gas fireplaces

Ventless gas fireplaces are essentially auxiliary heat sources, like electric heaters. You can place one anywhere in your home. The hot air blows back into your room rather than escaping up a chimney, which means some carbon dioxide and water vapor will be released back into your space, too. Regardless of which gas fireplace you choose, keep this information in mind.

  • Remember that the logs will burn hot, so you should keep all combustible materials at a safe distance from the fireplace.

  • Make sure the gas fireplace has a working oxygen depletion sensor. This will shut off the fire if too little oxygen is detected in the room.

  • Ventless fireplaces produce water vapor as a byproduct. Humidity levels in the home can rise and increase the risk of mold growth.

Vented gas fireplaces

With a vented fireplace, the combustion byproducts vent out of your home. Most come as inserts, which means you must place the gas fireplace insert in a firebox (if one isn’t included) and connect it to your existing chimney.

Content Image
Expert tip
The recommended best practice is to use ventless units for no more than two to three hours at a time because of the toxic gas risk. Vented gas fireplaces must be operated with your chimney’s damper open.
BestReviews Home Improvement and DIY Expert

Other gas fireplace features to consider

Fuel type

Gas fireplaces are fueled by either natural gas or liquid propane.

  • Natural gas is the best choice for people who already use natural gas in their homes. You may need to run a new gas line to your fireplace. The advantage of natural gas is that your fuel won’t run out.

  • Liquid propane is the alternative when natural gas is unavailable. You’ll need to purchase a propane tank and refill it as necessary.

Logs

All gas fireplaces come with logs made of ceramic, refractory cement, or another material. Some logs look more realistic than others. Do you want something that looks like a particular type of wood, such as birch or oak? Do you prefer a split-log design, or would you like logs that show a bit of bark? Your choice comes down to personal preference.

Heat output

In order to make sure you have enough heat output for your space, do a quick calculation of the  British thermal units (BTU) per hour you will need. BTU is a standard measurement defined as the amount of heat it takes to heat one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit.

Follow these steps to determine how many BTUs you need.

  1. Calculate the square footage of your space. For most spaces, a simple calculation of the length and width of your room will give you a square-footage estimate.

  2. Multiply the square footage by the recommended number of BTUs per hour per square foot. This recommendation varies by climate and the efficiency/age of your home. If you live in a colder climate, you will need between 50 to 60 BTUs per hour per square foot. Warmer climates require only about 30 to 35 BTUs per hour per square foot.

  3. Check the hourly BTU rate provided by the gas fireplace. The range of hourly BTU rates for home gas fireplaces is about 20,000 to 32,000.
Expert tip
Do not use any chemicals to clean the logs. Chemicals can create noxious fumes when heated. Gently clean the gas logs with a soft bristle brush or vacuum attachment.
BestReviews Home Improvement and DIY Expert

Gas fireplace prices

Gas fireplaces range in price from $350 to over $3,000. The broad categories below provide a general idea of what you can expect to find at each price point.

Inexpensive

Most of the gas fireplaces that cost between $350 and $800  are inserts or freestanding portable units. Many come with a wooden mantel to create a homey look.

Mid-range

You’ll find some fully vented gas fireplaces that insert into an existing chimney for $800 to $1,500. Some will have bonus features like remote start. These fireplaces tend to look more realistic, offering a higher number of burners and attractive logs.

Expensive

Most high-end gas fireplaces are very powerful and look extremely realistic. If you’re looking for an oblong or rectangular unit, you’ll probably need to spend more than $1,500.

Content Image
Caution
The glass front on a gas fireplace can get hot enough to cause a severe burn. Keep children and pets away from a gas fireplace that’s in use, and teach them about the danger.
STAFF
BestReviews

Tips

  • Consider buying a blower. While all gas fireplaces are designed to recirculate hot air back into your living space, not all are designed with electric blowers. You may want to consider buying a separate blower if yours doesn’t have one.

  • Choose a unit with temperature control. Gas fireplaces can get extremely hot. Those with temperature controls allow you to use and enjoy them without getting overheated.

  • Shut your gas fireplace down after a couple of hours. This practice is crucially important for ventless fireplaces. Reducing the time you use it will help prevent the buildup of potentially dangerous gases.
  • Get a carbon monoxide detector. A working carbon monoxide detector must be present in any home using a gas fireplace regardless of type. 
Content Image
Some freestanding gas fireplaces come with an authentic-looking mantel for enhanced ambience.

FAQ

Q. Can I install a vented gas fireplace if my home doesn’t have a chimney?

A.  Yes, you can enjoy the beauty and warmth of an installed fireplace without the expense of masonry or a chimney, but you need to have the right ductwork and the right kind of venting system. Direct venting system ductwork can enable a home without a chimney to use a vented gas fireplace. The venting system can be installed through the roof or through the backside of the home.

Q. Can I burn wood in my gas fireplace?

A. Gas fireplaces are designed to burn natural gas or propane fuel only. Attempting to burn wood or other materials in your gas fireplace will void the warranty and could damage your fireplace.

Q. Can the glass be removed from my gas fireplace?

A. Gas fireplaces are designed as a system. Removing the glass would reduce the fuel efficiency of that system. The glass should only be removed for cleaning when the gas fireplace is not in use.

BestReviews wants to be better. Please take our 3-minute survey,
and give us feedback about your visit today.

Take Survey