Distances itself from others on our list for its triple-action properties – removes and prevents stains while protecting sensitive teeth by helping to strengthen enamel. Consumers rave about the creamy consistency, clean feeling, and mint flavor.
Users with tough, set-in stains may see mixed results or require longer use before a noticeable difference.
A natural toothpaste that uses activated charcoal to whiten teeth, which isn't likely to cause irritation or tooth pain. Has peppermint oil for a fresh flavor. Less pricey than other charcoal formulas.
Noticeable results may take a while or be minimal for users with badly stained teeth.
With a combination of micro-cleansing silica and Whitelock formula, it provides noticeable results for many users plus prevents new stains. Minty flavor. An affordable toothpaste by a top brand in dental care.
The newly-designed cap is flimsy and hard to close tightly. Some users report less than 90% stain improvement – the percentage touted by the company.
Earns praise from those who have sensitive teeth for its natural silica formula that gently removes most stains. Unlike some other natural brands, it contains fluoride that helps prevent cavities. Peppermint flavor.
May not be effective on hard-to-remove stains, such as those caused by smoking or coffee drinking.
Not only is this toothpaste made by a top-selling brand, but it gets rave reviews for its ability to remove stains for leaving a "clean" feeling in the mouth. Has a fresh mint flavor; contains baking soda. It's also affordable.
Contains peroxide, which is known to cause tooth sensitivity and gum irritation in some users and/or with frequent use.
We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.
You know what they say: you never get a second chance to make a good first impression. You want to be memorable, but not because your teeth are yellowed, stained, or discolored. Your smile is one of your greatest assets, and one of the best ways to make sure people remember that smile is to flash teeth that are as pearly and bright as possible. Teeth whitening toothpaste can help.
While you aren’t likely to achieve movie star results from OTC teeth whitening products, you can noticeably diminish discoloration and improve the brightness of your teeth with a whitening toothpaste. But which one?
BestReviews is here to help. It’s our mission to provide shopping guides that you can sink your teeth into – all facts and no fluff. If you’re ready to buy some teeth whitening toothpaste, check out or top picks above. If you’d like to learn more about these products, keep reading our shopping guide below.
There are many factors that cause teeth to darken, yellow, or discolor. Some affect the exterior of the tooth (extrinsic stains). Brushing with a whitening toothpaste can help diminish extrinsic stains caused by the following.
Wine, grape juice
Berries, tomato sauce, and other foods
Some factors discolor the tooth beneath the enamel (intrinsic stains). Only chemical bleaching can help improve intrinsic stains caused by the following.
Aging (As the enamel thins, more yellow dentin shows through.)
Antibiotics (such as tetracycline)
While there are many different OTC products out there for whitening teeth – from chewing gums to rinses to strips to gels – toothpaste makes up the largest share of the market by far, which isn’t surprising when you think about it.
Whitening toothpaste is easy to use. Why not get a whitening boost out of an activity you’re already doing regularly?
Whitening toothpaste can be gentler on your teeth and gums than whitening strips, kits, or the gels that dentists use for in-office treatment.
Whitening toothpaste is inexpensive compared to in-office treatments and many whitening strips and kits.
Whitening toothpaste is safe and effective when used as directed.
Ease sensitivity, brighten your smile, block new stains, and prevent cavities – what’s not to love? Users rave about the minty taste, creamy texture, and gentle stain-removing qualities of this toothpaste. For teeth that feel like they spent the day at a spa, this is one to try.
Whitening toothpastes rely on an abrasive, such as tasteless and odorless hydrated silica, to scrub stains off the surface of teeth.
Some whitening toothpastes also include a low concentration of a bleaching agent, such as peroxide, to help brighten teeth.
Potential side effects include tooth sensitivity and irritation of gums and other soft tissues in the mouth. These can be avoided by using a product that doesn’t contain peroxide or a foaming agent called sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS).
Whitening toothpaste only removes surface stains. The best whitening toothpaste out there is worthless if you don’t take care of your teeth. Brush, floss, avoid sugary foods and sodas, and drink plenty of water.
A study by the American Academy of Cosmetic Dentistry found that 48% people think a smile is the most memorable feature after first meeting someone, compared to what the person says (25%) or wears (9%).
Cost may be one of your primary considerations when choosing a whitening procedure. While OTC products like toothpastes, kits, and strips cost significantly less than in-office procedures, there is a trade-off. Dentists use a much stronger bleaching agent for in-office treatments, and sometimes, only one visit is required. For several hundred dollars, you can see more rapid and dramatic results than you would get from an in-home whitening method.
You need to keep using whitening toothpaste in order to improve or maintain your results. Still, you’d have to go through a lot of tubes of toothpaste before you matched the cost of one in-office procedure.
Expect to pay between $1 and $2 per ounce for a five-ounce tube of teeth whitening toothpaste. Note, however, that there are bargains out there if you buy in bulk. You can find packages of multiple tubes that work out to a price as low as $0.17 per ounce.
Brighten your smile for pennies a day
Longtime Colgate fans love the brightening effects of baking soda and peroxide. Add fluoride to fight cavities and pure oxygen bubbles for freshness, and you can liven up your mouth for a price that’s hard to resist.
Dentists recommend that you replace your toothbrush every three to four months.
Brush your teeth twice a day with a soft-bristled brush held at a 45° angle. Using a hard brush or brushing too vigorously can damage your teeth and lead to tooth sensitivity.
Don’t go overboard with whitening. An attractive smile is a healthy white, not an unnatural white.
Once your teeth are whitened, try to avoid red wine, coffee, tea, grape juice, berries, tomato sauce, and other foods that can stain teeth. When you do consume them, rinse your mouth with water afterward.
Whitening your teeth with toothpaste is an ongoing process. Don’t expect to use the product for a week or two and be done.
Treat any existing dental problems, such as cavities, before using a whitening toothpaste or any other whitening product.
Q. Will using a whitening toothpaste make my teeth more sensitive?
A. Depending on the whitening chemicals in the product, you could experience tooth or gum sensitivity, especially if you have tooth decay or receding gums. Many whitening products contain peroxide, which can cause tooth sensitivity or gum irritation. Some clinical studies have shown that using a toothpaste containing potassium nitrate (such as a toothpaste formulated specifically for sensitive teeth) for a few weeks before and during whitening can reduce the sensitivity caused by the whitening procedure. Some whitening toothpastes also include potassium nitrate.
You will also find some whitening toothpastes that include sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS). This is a common foaming ingredient in personal care products, but it can cause skin irritation. If you have sensitive teeth or gums, read the ingredient list of any products you want to use. There are whitening toothpastes that do not include hydrogen peroxide or SLS.
Q. Does whitening toothpaste work as well as other whitening treatments?
A. The abrasives in the toothpaste remove stains on the enamel. The whitening agents in toothpaste are weaker than those used for in-office whitening and those found in at-home whitening kits or strips. The results you get from whitening toothpaste will probably be less dramatic and take longer to see than those from other whitening procedures.
Q. I’m worried about chemicals but still want to whiten my teeth. What can I do?
A. We all put toothpaste in our mouths every day, but you wouldn’t want to eat it. And children should not be allowed to ingest it. There are whitening toothpastes on the market that don’t contain peroxide, SLS, preservatives, or artificial coloring or sweeteners. They use ingredients such as food-grade activated charcoal, coconut oil, aloe vera, sea salt, and herbal extracts; these toothpastes are often marketed as “natural.”
Be aware that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has no definition for the term “natural” in food labeling, so it can mean whatever manufacturers want it to mean. However, products labeled “organic” must meet standards set by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. If you want to avoid ingesting certain chemicals, your best bet is to carefully read the ingredient list on the packaging.
BestReviews wants to be better. Please take our 3-minute survey,
and give us feedback about your visit today.