Menu
Updated January 2023
Header Image
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
Bottom line
Pros
Cons
Best of the Best
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail
Munchkin
Step Diaper Pail
Check Price
Built to Last
Bottom Line

A sleek, hands-free design that tops the list because of its impressive capacity and odor-control capabilities from a brand that earns our baby expert's approval.

Pros

This easy-to-use model features a no-touch foot pedal opening and Arm & Hammer odor control cartridges. Boasts a high capacity that holds more than 100 newborn diapers. Company plants a tree with each pail sold.

Cons

At more than 12 pounds, it's the heaviest model we reviewed. We find this to be a small concern, considering the quality.

Best Bang for the Buck
Dekor Hands-Free Diaper Pail
Dekor
Hands-Free Diaper Pail
Check Price
Simple Yet Solid
Bottom Line

Our baby expert appreciates the hands-free convenience of this affordably priced pail.

Pros

Sports a wide foot pedal and soft self-closing lid that traps odors. Comes at a mid-range price. Has a wider opening that allows for easy loading.

Cons

Some testers noticed that it doesn't always trap odors very well. It's also a bit wide.

Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail
Ubbi
Steel Diaper Pail
Check Price
Durable & Rugged
Bottom Line

This tough steel diaper pail provides a durable metal alternative to standard plastic models.

Pros

A durable design constructed with a steel exterior and rubber interior seals. Uses standard trash bags rather than specialized products. Has a slim, attractive appearance. Holds up to 55 diapers. Available in 10 colors to match nurseries.

Cons

One of the priciest models on the market, but not the best at odor control or capacity — only holds 50 diapers.

Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
Safety 1st
Easy Saver Diaper Pail
Check Price
Best for Small Spaces
Bottom Line

If you're tight on space, this simple pail gets the job done with few bells and whistles without requiring special bags

Pros

A lightweight model that works with any type of trash bags. One-handed use lets you keep the other on baby for safety. Comes with deodorizing disc.

Cons

The lid is somewhat awkward to shut, which means that odors have a tendency to escape.

Playtex Diaper Genie Complete
Playtex
Diaper Genie Complete
Check Price
Trusted Brand
Bottom Line

This plastic, anti-microbial pail clamps shut to trap odors inside. It's taller and takes no bending to reach.

Pros

Convenient design opens for bag removal at front so you don't need to move the pail. Clamps, thick collection bag, and specialized carbon filter bagging system combat odors. Foot pedal design for opening.

Cons

Some note that it requires a bit of force to get the diaper into the collection bin. Reviews of its odor control capabilities are mixed.

HOW WE TESTED

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

30
Models
Considered
95
Consumers
Consulted
8
Hours
Researched
Category cover

Buying guide for Best diaper pails

As a new parent, figuring out where to put a soiled diaper may not sit high on your to-do list, but since babies average around 10 diaper changes per day, a hygienic disposal system is essential.

The problem is, a regular household trash can doesn’t usually do the best job containing odors. Running outside to get rid of smelly deposits one by one isn’t very practical, either.

Offering superior odor control and a dedicated spot to dump dirty diapers, a diaper pail is the go-to solution for many parents. However, with a vast selection of diaper pails available, choosing a good one is nothing to sniff at.

Content Image
Most babies need to be changed every two to three hours. Having a diaper pail close at hand will not only make things easier, it will help you keep your nursery fresh as well.

 

"A great diaper pail shouldn't just trap odors; it should also be easy to use."
STAFF
BestReviews

Why you need a diaper pail

During the first few months of your baby's life, odor control may not be too much of a concern. Although using a diaper pail will still help keep things fresh, hygienic, and organized, its fundamental purpose may only truly have a chance to shine following the introduction of solids to your baby's diet.

Once those solid foods are part of your child’s everyday fare, a diaper pail offers hassle-free convenience – a quality that any busy parent can appreciate.

If you’re debating whether to get a diaper pail or make do with your regular trash can, consider a few reasons why a diaper pail makes life easier.

Expert tip
To avoid odors escaping, make sure the lid of your diaper pail is fully closed.
BestReviews Baby and Child Expert

Soiled diapers often emit odors capable of bringing tears to the eyes of grown men and cowboys.

  • Even if you own a good trash can with a tight-fitting lid, the bad smells will escape whenever you open it, and you'll likely be facing a full-on olfactory assault each time.

  • A diaper pail has a sealed lid that's specifically designed to trap odors inside – and keep them inside.

  • Some diaper pails take your olfactory comfort a step further with additional odor-control methods, like the use of scented disks.

Indeed, the presence of a diaper pail in your home can definitely help make the diapering years more pleasant for everyone.

Checklist: the most desirable diaper pail features

Liner compatibility

Not all liners are compatible with all diaper pails.

Some pails require proprietary liners that are admittedly expensive – but also easier to change. Other pails can accommodate more than one style of liner. Still others can make use of ordinary trash bags.

Content Image
Expert tip
Diaper pails that use regular trash bags are nice because then you don’t have to buy special bags.
BestReviews Baby and Child Expert

Aesthetics

If you've already invested a significant amount of time, effort, and money in creating the perfect environment for your little one, finding a diaper pail with a design that complements your nursery décor is a worthwhile endeavor.

However, keep in mind that time spent in the nursery won't be nearly as pleasant under an oppressive cloud of funk, and functionality should always come before an attractive exterior.

Ease of use

Juggling a baby and a dirty diaper is something most parents do on a daily basis. A diaper pail that opens and closes with minimal effort can be a lifesaver. Models with foot pedals or one-handed operation offer the highest levels of convenience.

Removing and changing the liner of a diaper pail should also be as fuss-free as possible.

  • Some diaper pails have continuous liners and built-in cutters that allow you to easily snip and tie off full bags.

  • Some diaper pails have bags that can simply be snapped shut before removal. These are by far the easiest to deal with, but they generally require special liners.

Odor control

All diaper pails provide some level of odor control, but many have features beyond a tightly sealed lid to help make them even more effective.

  • Built-in fragrance disks, odor-absorbing carbon filters, and baking soda sachets can help mask or absorb unpleasant smells.

  • Double-barriers can also be extremely effective. Some diaper pails have sliding or spring-loaded trap doors under the lid to help keep odors from escaping upon opening.

  • Some diaper pails have a clamp-lock design that closes the liner opening to keep wafting fumes to a minimum, even when the lid is up.

"If the cost or availability of replacement liners is a major concern for you, consider a versatile diaper pail that doesn't impose strict liner refill requirements. For example, some diaper pails work well with regular trash bags."
STAFF
BestReviews

Dirty diaper capacity

When selecting a diaper pail, don't forget to consider its capacity.

If you have more than one child in diapers, you'll want to opt for a larger model.

Keep in mind, too, that toddler diapers consume more space. A pail that holds 50 newborn diapers would certainly not have enough space for 50 toddler diapers.

Content Image
For your safety
To minimize the chance of your diaper pail absorbing odors, don't allow soiled diapers to sit for too long. Change the liner every couple of days.
STAFF
BestReviews

Diaper pail prices

Diaper pails generally cost between $20 and $80, with pricier models sporting a higher number of odor-control features and other added conveniences.

Capacity can also affect price, with larger diaper pails costing more than smaller varieties.

Most mid-range diaper pails priced between $30 and $60 offer a good balance of affordability, efficiency, and convenience.

"Don't forget to factor in the cost of liner refills when choosing a diaper pail. Bear in mind that some diaper pails can only be used with liners made by the pail manufacturer."
STAFF
BestReviews
Content Image
You might be drawn to the idea of a “compact” diaper pail when your baby is an infant, but as she grows, you may find yourself wishing for a pail with a larger capacity. Keep this in mind as you shop.

FAQ

Q. Can I use a diaper pail for cloth diapers?

A. A handful of diaper pails are designed for use with cloth diapers as well as disposable diapers. For the most part, however, regular diaper pails may not be suitable for the added bulk and weight of cloth diapers.

If you use cloth diapers and are drawn to the notion of the superior odor control offered by regular diaper pails, select a pail with the following characteristics.

  • Created for use with both disposable and cloth diapers

  • Able to accommodate the added bulk of cloth diapers

  • Sturdy enough to hold the extra weight of cloth diapers

  • Easy to clean, should leaks occur

Expert tip
Hands-free pails or easy-to-open lids are important because parents always have their hands full.
BestReviews Baby and Child Expert

Q. Should I wash my diaper pail?

A. Yes. To prevent mold and bacterial growth, it's a good idea to wash your diaper pail at least once a week using warm, soapy water or an antibacterial cleaning solution. After rinsing, wipe the pail down with a dry cloth and allow it to air dry for a few hours before replacing the liner and closing it up.

For stubborn odors, try using a vinegar/water rinse, or place a small tray of baking soda in the bottom of the pail to help absorb lingering odors.

There is one caveat to this answer, and that applies to steel diaper pails. Steel diaper pails should not be washed, as this could cause them to rust. If you use a steel diaper pail, keep it as dry as possible, and always follow manufacturer cleaning instructions.

Q. Will I be able to use my diaper pail for other purposes once my child is out of diapers?

A. Absolutely. If you'd like to get the most out of your diaper pail, there's no reason not to use it as a regular trash can once the diapering years are behind you. And if you happen to have cats, an old diaper pail is perfect for used cat litter, too.

Q. I don’t look forward to emptying the diaper pail, so I bought a fairly large one. How often will I need to change it?

A. Although you shouldn't have to empty your diaper pail every day, one that's too large can become a barrel of brewing nastiness over time. For the most effective odor control, change your diaper liner at least every two to three days, regardless of its capacity.

Our Top Picks