We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.
A quality mattress topper will be part of a consumer's sleep system for years, so it needs to be durable. Polyurethane foam is a common base ingredient, but it is not especially supportive by itself. Most manufacturers inject special gels to increase viscosity. The result of this injection is commonly known as "memory foam." Mattress toppers are often constructed in layers, each of which serves a specific purpose (ventilation, comfort, support, and so on.) In this section, we note how each top contender combines ingredients to create the best night's sleep possible.
Most people have their own personal preferences when it comes to bedding. Some prefer a firm, supportive mattress; others seek a softer, more forgiving surface. This philosophy holds true for mattress toppers as well. The invention of memory foam has revolutionized the home bedding industry, but some people find the material too unforgiving. Some mattress toppers provide little natural ventilation, causing users to feel overly hot after a few hours of slumber. Here, we evaluate each contender in terms of firmness and comfort.
Because mattress toppers are constructed of water-absorbing polyurethane foam, they cannot be machine washed. Mattress toppers require the same care as the mattresses they protect, and proper maintenance is essential. Users should become familiar with common cleaning methods. Because these foam pads are cut to standard mattress sizes, they can be challenging to install and remove. If not handled carefully, a mattress topper could easily be torn or punctured. In this section, we note any maintenance or durability issues associated with our top five contenders.
Bargain-priced models can correct some common issues (uneven mattress surface, weak lumbar support) without breaking the bank. Some high-end mattress toppers could theoretically replace a traditional spring mattress. Before committing to a purchase, consumers should consider their personal bedding needs and preferences.
While other memory foam mattress toppers tend to use a one-piece design, the Sleep Innovations Dual Layer mattress topper employs two separate layers for improved comfort and ventilation. One layer, filled with a down alternative, is closer to a traditional "pillow top" mattress pad. The other layer is a two-inch thick memory foam pad. When sandwiched together, the down alternative layer provides ventilation and comfort, and the memory foam layer provides therapeutic support. Our only concern about this dual layer arrangement is the chance of slippage during sleep. A 72-hour decompression period is advised before using the Sleep Innovations mattress topper.
Memory Foam Solutions' Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress topper is an American-made product that meets or exceeds the requirements for PURGreen certification. This is an important consideration, because some mattress topper manufacturers still use a petroleum-based form of polyurethane foam that can create long-lasting fumes and other environmental issues. This mattress topper features a three-inch layer of four-pound density memory foam, a configuration that most back sleepers find particularly supportive. Side sleepers, on the other hand, may want to seek out a mattress topper in the two or three-pound density range.
If you are a side sleeper, there are actually some mattress toppers dedicated to supporting this position.
The LUCID 3 Inch Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper uses an open-cell design that allows for a lot more natural ventilation than its closed-cell competitors. More ventilation means less opportunity for unpleasant heat retention during use. We estimate the density level of the LUCID's memory foam to be approximately three pounds, which may not be quite enough for heavier users or those who prefer an extra-firm sleeping surface. We praise the LUCID for its relatively short decompression period, its natural resistance to mites and other allergens, and the fact that its gel-infused memory foam adjusts to the user's body temperature and pressure points.
One thing that sets the Sleep Joy ViscO2 Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper apart from the competition is its use of eco-friendly plant material. By incorporating these natural materials instead of the more common oil-based ingredients, no extended de-fumigation period is required. Once the Sleep Joy ViscO2 has been unpacked, it needs just a short period of time to decompress. (The topper's open-cell foam design allows for this. It also promotes improved natural ventilation!) Some critics note that the Sleep Joy ViscO2 should not be described or marketed as a true memory foam product; rather, they say it should be touted a "gel-enhanced" traditional foam mattress topper. Owners tell us that the Sleep Joy is not quite as firm as other memory foam mattress toppers, but they do say that it has the elasticity and "give" found in other top contenders. Consumers who want the thick consistency of a high-end memory foam topper might want to look elsewhere, but many satisfied users tell us that the Sleep Joy ViscO2 meets their soft to medium-soft support expectations.
The 3.3. Cloud9 Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Topper may not have the viscosity of a high-end memory foam topper, but it does offer high-end support for users. Some people have compared it to budget-priced polyurethane "egg crate" foam mattress toppers, but its gel-filled memory foam layer definitely gives it added value. The 3.3 Cloud9 mattress topper is rated at two to three pounds of density, but potential buyers should note that the company also offers versions with densities of four and five pounds. Users report only minimal off-gassing during the 24-hour period after arrival; total decompression time is often less than the recommend 48 hours. Potential buyers should be sure to select a mattress topper density that corresponds with their body weight. Indeed, heavier users could be disappointed by the level of support provided by the 3.3 Cloud9's two or three-pound density offerings.
Check your mattress topper's warranty before buying. Some begin to lose their shape quickly if they are low quality. A warranty will give you time to test out your mattress topper thoroughly.
The dual layers of the Sleep Innovations mattress topper measure a total of four inches, which puts it at a medium-soft to medium level of support and comfort. Most users under 200 pounds should feel a positive difference when the Sleep Innovations mattress topper is added to their existing bed. The fabric layer helps level out the pressure points of the mattress, while the memory foam layer conforms to the sleeper's unique body dimensions. The use of a temperature-sensitive cooling gel helps reduce the excessive heat retention often experienced by memory foam users. The fabric layer can be placed over or under the memory foam layer, depending to the user's preference. We especially like the fact that owners can choose to use the fabric topper, the memory foam layer, or both at once.
Memory foam is often rated by density per foot; this measure is expressed in pounds. In the case of Memory Foam Solution's Visco Elastic mattress topper, its four-pound density provides soft to medium support. Because the foam is temperature-sensitive, however, the actual level of support will fluctuate. Many satisfied customers tell us that, once the Visco Elastic mattress topper has had time to adjust to the user's body, it does an excellent job of eliminating pressure points. The manufacturer recommends an initial 96-hour decompression period before first use. The memory foam needs time to reach an ambient room temperature for maximum viscosity. Some owners note a bit heat retention after a few hours of use, but this is an inherent problem with denser materials like memory foam gel. The use of a mattress pad or other covering is encouraged for both comfort and ventilation.
If you are just looking for a thin barrier between you and your mattress, a mattress pad may be the way to go. If you need extra comfort in a serious way, it’s time to invest in a topper.
Excessive heat retention is a common complaint among memory foam users. The LUCID memory foam mattress topper addresses this issue through natural open-cell ventilation and a heat-sensitive gel infusion. The topper's three-inch depth helps level out sags and dips in the mattress below it, but because of its innate flexibility, it will also follow the contours of the mattress. This means that an older mattress with a pronounced sag or central dip will not be completely restored to its original state. Nevertheless, many satisfied owners tell us that the LUCID does indeed improve the quality of their sleep and provides sufficient therapeutic support for aching joints and muscles.
The Sleep Joy ViscO2 mattress topper does not require a lengthy decompression and aeration period to deal with toxic chemical off-gassing. Most users report little to no odor just 24 hours after opening the package. The Sleep Joy's three-inch depth should provide enough support for lighter users (under 200 pounds), but heavier users may find it to be too soft. The foam is not sturdy enough to restore a sagging mattress to its former glory, but it does improve support for essential pressure points. The pad's open-cell ventilation system minimizes heat retention somewhat, but some users still report a noticeable warmth during the overnight hours. The addition of a mattress protector should help improve this heat retention problem.
When it comes to memory foam mattress toppers, user comfort is a subjective thing. Some people find four or five pounds of foam density to be ideal; others prefer two or three pounds of density. In the case of the 3.3 Cloud9 Visco Elastic mattress topper, people who weigh less than 150 pounds will find this version to be very supportive and comfortable. However, heavier users may want to consider upgrading to a Cloud9 model with higher density ratings. Ventilation is much improved with the addition of a cotton mattress protector between the user and the mattress topper. Heat retention is always a concern with memory foam products, but many satisfied users tell us that the Cloud9 mattress topper is far more comfortable than some of the high-end latex-based models they've tried in the past.
Most mattress toppers are between 1” and 4”. Most people are set with a 2” topper unless they suffer from a particularly hard mattress.
While other mattress covers with memory foam are not machine washable, the dual layer Sleep Innovations Mattress Topper includes a fabric-based section that can be washed and dried conventionally. The memory foam layer cannot be fully immersed in water, but it can be sprayed with a commercial or homemade bed refresher and air-dried. To enhance durability, the entire mattress topper can be covered with a deep fitted sheet or other bed protector.
When the Memory Foam Solutions' mattress topper is shipped to customers, it is in a state of heavy compression. Users must place it in an open, ventilated area and allow it to decompress for up to 96 hours. This allows the topper to reach an ideal temperature and also discharge most (if not all) of its residual production odors. The mattress topper is cut to standard mattress sizes, which can make it challenging for one person to manipulate. The foam can be torn during handling, and punctures are also possible. Since the mattress foam cannot be machine-washed, we recommend maintaining it with commercial or homemade mattress refreshers or light-duty surface wipes.
If part of your sleep woes come from a restless bed partner, a memory foam topper can minimize their movement on your side of the bed.
The LUCID ventilated memory foam mattress topper can be decompressed and ready to go in 24 hours, which is relatively fast compared to some of our other top contenders. Users report a minimal amount of lingering odor during and after the decompression period. (The typical odor dissipation period is 48 hours.) The topper itself weighs 20 pounds, and it should be handled with care to avoid tearing. Most users place their toppers directly on the original mattress and hold it in place with a fitted sheet. Using an additional bed protector is thought to extend the lifespan of the mattress topper even further. We recommend airing out the LUCID mattress topper periodically to allow the foam's open cells to restore themselves. The manufacturer's three-year warranty is fairly standard, but consumers should read the conditions carefully.
Most memory foam mattress toppers remain viable for at least three years, and the Sleep Joy ViscO2 is no exception. Its open-cell construction allows the pad to vent excess air into the room, removing a common source of destructive stress. There is no "up" or "down" when it comes to the ViscO2's memory foam layer, so it can be turned periodically to reduce wear and tear. As with most memory foam bedding, the ViscO2 cannot be machine washed, but spot cleaning (with an approved cleaning solution) is possible. Owners praise the Sleep Joy ViscO2 for its eco-friendly composition and super-soft texture.
The 3.3 Cloud9 Memory Foam Mattress Topper comes with an incredible 20-year limited warranty. Indeed, the manufacturer strongly believes in this product's durability. The lifespan of most mattress toppers is three or four years, but the 3.3 Cloud9 has what it takes to last much longer. This mattress topper is about half the weight of most of our other shortlist contenders, making it ideal for students and the elderly. Potential buyers should note that some slippage can occur if the topper isn't secured by a fitted sheet or mattress protector with straps. Also, the Cloud9 topper is not machine-washable, so it should be cleaned periodically with a fabric refresher spray and aired out to retain its foam density.
There are many different types of mattress pads, like latex, memory foam, and egg crate. Many have synthetic materials, so double check they won’t affect your allergies.
The Sleep Innovations Dual Layer's retail price of $172 is not a misprint. Customers looking for an affordable upgrade to a memory foam sleep system will find it here. While other memory foam mattress toppers can be difficult to maneuver, the Sleep Innovations' dual layers can be added separately. The manufacturer offers a 10-year limited warranty, which is unusually generous in the bedding industry.
While the original retail price of a high-end memory foam mattress topper can be as much as an entire spring mattress, the Memory Foam Solutions' current price point of $135 makes it an attractive alternative. This item arrives with a three-year warranty, which is the estimated lifespan of most mattress toppers. Considering how expensive and inconvenient it can be to replace a sagging mattress with an entirely new one, investing in a quality mattress topper makes good economic sense. Some users have even reported replacing their aging mattresses with two Visco Elastic memory foam mattress toppers sandwiched together. This is the sign of an amazingly comfortable and affordable product!
For hot sleepers, a down mattress topper will keep you cooler than memory foam.
At $73, the LUCID Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper is among the more expensive contenders on our shortlist. Many satisfied users say it's worth the additional investment because of its natural ventilation and cooling memory gel infusion. The LUCID can be decompressed and installed in a day or so if necessary. As such, it is definitely a product to consider if a fast "turn around" time is on your priority list. Some users have older mattresses in their guest rooms that need immediate improvement before guests arrive. A memory foam mattress topper like the LUCID would definitely prove useful in such a situation.
At a retail price of $124, The Sleep Joy ViscO2 mattress topper is more of a mid-range option than an entry level/budget-friendly model. It is not designed to take the place of a high-end memory foam mattress topper with a five-pound density rating and a generous gel infusion. Rather, it's an affordable upgrade from the standard polyurethane "egg shell" mattress topper that offers little in the way of pressure point support. Many satisfied users tell us the Sleep Joy ViscO2 provides instant relief from the detrimental physical effects of an older mattress. That may be reason enough to invest in this mid-range topper instead of a new mattress!
Many memory foam mattress toppers start out at a high price only to be promoted at a deep discount during a bedding sale. The Cloud9 mattress topper, at a cost of $94, is a good example of this. Memory foam is a coveted material for numerous bedding items, but not all products with memory foam are worth the additional investment. The 3.3 Cloud9 mattress topper may not have the density and foam memory of its high-end counterparts, but it does provide the same steady support over time. In short, it provides owners a great introduction to memory foam without requiring a substantial financial investment.
Many shoppers look at entire sleep systems with memory foam mattress toppers only to find that they are either too expensive or not as comfortable as advertised. One affordable solution to that quandary is the addition of a high-quality mattress topper to an existing bed. The consumer gets a better night's rest by sleeping on a supportive surface that conforms to his/her body contours, and the older mattress gets years added to its useful lifespan! While all of our top contenders are worth the investment, the environmentally conscious Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Mattress Topper is the Best of the Best!
While all memory foam mattress toppers have some issues with off-gassing and heat reflection/retention, the Sleep Innovations Mattress Topper uses natural, environmentally friendly materials that minimizes those concerns. Most owners report minimal problems with fumes after the initial 72-hour decompression period, and once the memory foam's internal temperature has stabilized, it becomes conveniently sensitive (and responsive) to changes in the environmental temperature. First-time memory foam customers find this particular model to be very user-friendly. It's especially great for back sleepers who prefer a soft or medium level of support. Side sleepers may also find it comfortable, but we recommend trying it out first if you tend to sleep on your side.
The Sleep Innovations Mattress Topper is an ideal choice for those who have never experienced memory foam before. If you're looking for an environmentally friendly, easy-to-use mattress topper of the utmost quality, this topper is at the top of our list!
If you're looking for an environmentally friendly, easy-to-use mattress topper of the utmost quality, the Sleep Innovations Mattress Topper is at the top of our list!
At BestReviews, we purchase every product we review with our own funds. We never accept anything from product manufacturers. Our goal is to be 100% objective in our analysis, and we do not want to run the risk of being swayed by products provided at no cost.