Best Feisty Pets

Updated January 2022
Header Image
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
Best of the Best
William Mark Glenda Glitterpoop the Unicorn
William Mark
Glenda Glitterpoop the Unicorn
Check Price
Fantasy Reimagined
Bottom Line

Children love fantasy animals (dragons, unicorns, fairies), and Glenda Glitterpoop definitely packs a dramatic punch when she shows her feisty face.

Pros

Might look cute at first, but Glenda Glitterpoop has a dark side. Doll switches from a sad, adorable unicorn to a fierce (but still cute) monstrosity. Kids will find it hilarious and adults are likely to enjoy it, too.

Cons

Top heavy design, tends to tip over. Some design flaws with mechanical parts. Some versions only stick out tongue, no teeth display.

Best Bang for the Buck
William Mark Princess Pottymouth the Cat
William Mark
Princess Pottymouth the Cat
Check Price
For Little Cat Lovers
Bottom Line

Princess Pottymouth represents the dual nature of their favorite cat well and its feisty face is scary, but not over-the-top for younger children.

Pros

The resting face might look like a cute little kitty princess, but with a few adjustments, she becomes as fierce as a lion or tiger. Younger children love the slightly darker take. Conversion to a feisty face is very easy and effective.

Cons

Relatively expensive for a plush toy. Construction issues, including weak seams and minimal stuffing. Smaller than expected.

William Mark Junkyard Jeff the Goat
William Mark
Junkyard Jeff the Goat
Check Price
Scary but Cute
Bottom Line

Goats are uncommon plush toy characters, but Junkyard Jeff has a special appeal to all ages and genders, adults will enjoy his drastic conversion.

Pros

Billy goat character appeals to kids of all ages who enjoy plush toys. Soft, plush construction with easy mechanical action that turns the adorable billy goat into a kid-friendly monster. Runs without batteries.

Cons

Some mechanical issues with mouth reported. Conversion from nice to feisty can be too intense.

William Mark Sammy Suckerpunch the Dog
William Mark
Sammy Suckerpunch the Dog
Check Price
Dog Lovers Rejoice
Bottom Line

Sammy Suckerpunch combines appeal of plush dog toy with sinister fun, is recommended for older kids, since the effect can be intense for toddlers.

Pros

Everyone loves a little stuffed dog, but sometimes they might want one with a little edge. Sammy is the answer. Makes for the perfect cuddle partner. Includes personalized name tag with likes and dislikes. Great shock value.

Cons

Some mechanical damage reported. Seams can rip under moderate play. Smaller than expected.

William Mark Vicky Vicious the Bunny
William Mark
Vicky Vicious the Bunny
Check Price
Best for Young Kids
Bottom Line

Adults will definitely appreciate the killer rabbit aspect, while younger owners will still embrace Vicky Vicious without the feisty face gimmick.

Pros

The contrast between resting and feisty face is very shocking while keeping its original appeal. The bunny character is popular with young children and older animal lovers alike. Scary, but in a cute and fun way.

Cons

Cheaply constructed, some premature fraying possible. Top heavy, tends to fall forward. Conversion mechanism can fail quickly.

HOW WE TESTED

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

Click here for testing insights
60
Models
Considered
60
Consumers
Consulted
18
Hours
Researched
Category cover

Feisty Pets are a fun twist on classic plush animals. When these animals arrive, they resemble any other friendly-looking stuffed animal. When squeezed behind the ears, though, their face transforms to display a “feisty,” aggressive expression. Feisty Pets are intended for older children – it takes some dexterity to operate them, and the “feisty” facial expressions may be too intense for younger children. Feisty Pets come in a variety of animal options, including some animals that are unusual to see as plush characters. They’re a unique, edgy toy that can make a much-appreciated gift for the right child. Be sure to examine the before and after pictures before purchasing.

Other Products We Considered
The BestReviews editorial team researches hundreds of products based on consumer reviews, brand quality, and value. We then choose a shorter list for in-depth research and testing before finalizing our top picks. These are the products we considered that ultimately didn't make our top 5.
Feisty Pets
Glenda Glitterpoop the Unicorn that Turns Feisty
Feisty Pets
8.5" Plush Stuffed Snow Leopard That Turns Feisty
Feisty Pets
Ferdinand Flamefart the Dragon
Feisty Pets
Paranoid Prisma The Rainbow Unicorn
Feisty Pets
Mary Monstertruck The Calico Cat
Feisty Pets
Ollie Olé The Plush Piñata
Feisty Pets
Karl The Snarl Plush Stuffed Polar Bear
Feisty Pets
Mini Black Cat
Feisty Pets
William Mark Junkyarde Jeff Plush Stuffed Goat
Feisty Pets
Plush Stuffed Chimmi Chimmi Bang Bang Chihuahua
See more
Our Top Picks
William Mark
Best of the Best
William Mark
Glenda Glitterpoop the Unicorn
Bottom Line
Children love fantasy animals (dragons, unicorns, fairies), and Glenda Glitterpoop definitely packs a dramatic punch when she shows her feisty face.
Shop Now
William Mark
Best Bang for the Buck
William Mark
Princess Pottymouth the Cat
Bottom Line
Princess Pottymouth represents the dual nature of their favorite cat well and its feisty face is scary, but not over-the-top for younger children.
Shop Now
William Mark
Top Pick
William Mark
Junkyard Jeff the Goat
Bottom Line
Goats are uncommon plush toy characters, but Junkyard Jeff has a special appeal to all ages and genders, adults will enjoy his drastic conversion.
Shop Now
William Mark
Top Pick
William Mark
Sammy Suckerpunch the Dog
Bottom Line
Sammy Suckerpunch combines appeal of plush dog toy with sinister fun, is recommended for older kids, since the effect can be intense for toddlers.
Shop Now
William Mark
Top Pick
William Mark
Vicky Vicious the Bunny
Bottom Line
Adults will definitely appreciate the killer rabbit aspect, while younger owners will still embrace Vicky Vicious without the feisty face gimmick.
Shop Now