BestReviews is reader-supported and may earn an affiliate commission. Details
Beyond reviews, our team aims to provide you with useful, compelling, and fun how-to guides, gift ideas, and deep dives into trendy products consumers like you love. Here are our latest articles.
September 19, 2022  |  Kitchen

Looking to replace your coffee maker before the cold weather hits? Here are 12 models worth checking out

Cold weather can be a drag, but a warm cup of rich coffee makes it more bearable. It might still be too warm to drink coffee consistently, but if you’re ready to replace your coffee maker, there’s no need to wait until the cold weather hits. Whether you want a simple upgrade or something more high-end, there are plenty of terrific coffee makers you can check out.

In this article: Keurig K-Classic Single Serve Coffee MakerNinja DualBrew System 12-cup Coffee Maker and Hamilton Beach Two-way Brewer Coffee Maker

How much coffee do you want to make?

If you live on your own or rarely drink coffee, a single-serve coffee maker is ideal since they’re compact and great for brewing one cup at a time. If you live in a household with over three people who drink several cups of coffee throughout the day or want a coffee maker for the office, it’s best to get a drip machine with a large capacity. Large drip coffee makers come with glass carafes and a warming plate that keeps coffee warm for several hours.

Programmable brewing

For those who don’t identify as a morning person, a coffee maker with a programmable brewing function is excellent. Instead of filling a coffee maker with water every morning and turning it on, coffee makers with a programmable function can be set to operate up to 24 hours ahead of time. Not only does this eliminate the hassle of running the coffee maker every morning, but you can have your coffee ready by the time your alarm sounds off in the morning.

Flavor richness and iced coffee

Some like their coffee to have a bold taste, while others prefer a regular brew. The best coffee makers come with multiple settings to make coffee with varying boldness. Some drip models even have a brew-over-ice function for making iced coffee.

Brewing speed

For those with a busy daily routine or a tight schedule, sitting around waiting for their coffee to be ready is impractical. If you’re constantly on the go, it’s best to look for a coffee maker with a fast brewing time. Also, some find that coffee left warming in a carafe sometimes has a burned taste, making a fast-brewing coffee maker ideal for those who want to avoid this.

Auto-off function

Even the most prudent person can be forgetful, making an auto-off function a must. Leaving any appliance running for an extended period poses a hazard and can cause electrical issues and potentially start a fire. As a safety precaution, many coffee-makers have a function that automatically turns them off after a few hours.

Best high-end coffee makers

Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker

This coffee maker makes regular and rich coffee brews with full flavor and has a 14-cup glass carafe. It has a small batch function for making 1 to 4 cups and a plate that keeps coffee warm for up to four hours.

Sold by Kohl’s

Moccamaster 10-Cup Coffee Maker

Those who don’t mind spending the money will love this fast-operating 10-cup coffee maker. It has a pre-immersion drip-style system, a cone-shaped brew basket that extracts the coffee’s flavor and an independent hot plate that can be kept at 175 to 185 degrees.

Sold by Wayfair

Keurig K-Supreme Gray Single Serve Coffee Brewer

This coffee maker can make four brew sizes and uses Multi-Stream technology to saturate coffee grounds evenly and extract full flavor. It has a 66-ounce water reservoir, and cups can be customized with a strong brew or brewed hot over ice.

Sold by Home Depot

Keurig K-Classic Single Serve Coffee Maker

This coffee maker can brew multiple 6-, 8- or 10-ounce cup pods with the 6-ounce delivering the strongest brew. It has a removable 48-ounce water reservoir, which lets users brew up to 6 cups before requiring a refill, and an auto-off function. 

Sold by Amazon

OXO 8-cup Stainless Steel Brew Coffee Maker

This coffee maker uses BetterPrecision technology to control water temperature, volume and brewing time to brew rich-tasting coffee. It has a double-wall, vacuum-insulated thermal carafe and a removable well cover that makes room for tall mugs.

Sold by Home Depot

Ninja DualBrew System 12-cup Coffee Maker

This coffee maker has nine ground brew sizes, four standard pod sizes and an adjustable warming plate for keeping coffee warm for up to four hours. It has a removable 60-ounce water reservoir and can make classic, rich and iced coffee.

Sold by Amazon

Best coffee makers under $100

Hamilton Beach Two-way Brewer Coffee Maker

You can use your favorite ground coffee to make either single-serve cups or full-pot brews, and control how strong you want your coffee with regular and bold brew settings. It comes with a mesh scoop, a two-hour auto-off function and a programmable timer.

Sold by Amazon

Cuisinart 12-cup Brew Central Coffee Maker

This fully-automated coffee brewer has 24-hour programmability with 1 to 4 cup settings, temperature control and auto-off functionality. It comes with a gold tone coffee filter, and the glass carafe has an ergonomic grip handle and can hold up to 12 cups.

Sold by Amazon

Black and Decker 12-cup Programmable Coffee Maker

This coffee maker has rubber buttons, an auto-off feature that activates after two hours and a screen that displays brew time, programming options and a clock. It has a front-facing window, and the plate keeps coffee warm for an hour.

Sold by Amazon

Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14-cup Coffee Maker

This coffee maker uses advanced technology to maintain coffee at the right temperature without sacrificing flavor and has options for making bold and regular brews. It has 24-hour programmability with 1 to 4 cup settings and a 14-cup glass carafe.

Sold by Amazon

Mr. Coffee Rapid Brew 12-cup Programmable Coffee Maker

This coffee maker is ideal for those with a busy schedule, as it works up to 20% faster than a standard coffee maker. It has a brew strength selector for choosing how bold you want your coffee to taste.

Sold by Kohl’s

Krups Simply Brew Coffee Maker

This is a fine choice for those who want a simple, affordable coffee maker. It has a compact design ideal for those with less space on their kitchen countertop, a 5-cup brewing capacity and an on-and-off switch for easy operation.

Sold by Amazon


Want to shop the best products at the best prices? Check out Daily Deals from BestReviews. 

Sign up here to receive the BestReviews weekly newsletter for useful advice on new products and noteworthy deals. 

Kevin Luna writes for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their purchasing decisions, saving them time and money.

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers.