Best stila Eyeliners

An easy-glide, quick-dry precision liner that's been an industry favorite for years.

Thin tip is easy to use. Doesn't skip or pull, making it easy to draw straight lines. Color is rich and stays on without feathering, running, or smudging. Reviewers said it was still easy to wash off at night. Available in a variety of colors.

Some reviewers said it was not as waterproof as other brands they tried.

Best Bang for the Buck

Despite a few quirks, stila's Smudge Pots offer long wear and attractive colors. A good pick for consumers who like to change up their eye looks.

This gel eyeliner is like having two products in one, thanks to the creamy consistency that can also be used as an eyeshadow. Product lasts. Colors are deeply pigmented and wear for hours. Can be used to create a wide range of looks.

Got Inked Cushion Eyeliner

Dries quickly, so if you prefer to smudge your eyeliner, you'll need to work fast. Will dry out fairly quickly if the lid isn't put on tightly. Requires a brush.

stila

Innovative Cushion Liner

Worth a look if you like liquid eyeliners and want to try something new. Can be used to tightline and for cat eye looks once you master using it.

Unique cushion liquid eyeliner in bold, rich colors. Available in both matte and metallic finishes. A little goes a long way, and it dries quickly. Doesn't tend to flake like some liquid liners. Colors last. Great for graphic eyeliner shapes.

Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Micro Tip

Product is prone to drying out if the lid isn't closed tightly when not in use. Comes with a learning curve, and the brush that's included is awkward to use.

stila

Best for Thin Lines

Choose this all-day eyeliner if you need to make ultra-fine lines. Ideal for precision work.

Just like the brand's top-selling Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner but with a super-fine tip. Perfect for drawing lines very close to the lashes or for creating ultra-fine wings. Waterproof, all-day wear and deeply pigmented colors.

Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner

Tends to dry out fairly quickly. If you like bolder lines, it probably won't work for you.

stila

Easy to Smudge

If you prefer traditional eyeliners that are soft and easy to smudge for smoky looks, this one lives up to its name.

Classic pencil that twists up, so no sharpening is required. Glides on effortlessly and can be smudged for softer lines. A good choice for consumers who like a smoky eye look. Colors are vivid and last for hours.