Buying guide for best men’s dress shoes

Whether it’s to wear with a classic suit for the office or an elegant tuxedo for a wedding, every man should have at least one good pair of dress shoes in his closet.

If you don’t know an Oxford from a loafer, though, choosing the right men’s dress shoes can seem like mission impossible. That’s because you don’t just have to settle on the right type of dress shoe – you need to find the right material, construction, color, embellishments, and other features to ensure that the shoes will not only complement your look but be durable, too.

At BestReviews, our goal is to make your shopping experience stress-free. Ready to buy a pair of men’s dress shoes? You’ll find our five favorites in the product list above. For everything you need to know about selecting the right dress shoes for your style, keep reading.

The most formal men’s dress shoes are patent leather, which has a high-shine finish. They’re best reserved for black tie occasions where you’ll be wearing a tuxedo.

Types of men’s dress shoes

Oxford

Oxfords are one of the most classic men’s dress shoe options on the market. Oxfords feature the following:

• Front laces

• Eyelet flaps sewn under the vamp, which covers the front of the foot

• Low heel

• Slim silhouette

• Sleek, minimal appearance

Derby

Derby dress shoes were originally sporting boots. Derby shoes are similar to Oxfords but feature the following:

• Eyelet flaps sewn on top of the vamp for open lacing

• Wider fit for increased comfort

• Versatile appearance that lends itself to both business casual and formal looks

Loafer

Loafers are moccasin-inspired dress shoes. Loafers feature the following:

• Slip-on design

• A saddle, or piece of decorative leather that lays across the top of the shoe, which may be plain, slitted, or adorned with metal hardware or tassels

• Elevated seam in the toe area

Monk strap

Monk strap dress shoes are similar to Oxfords, but they don’t have laces. Instead, monk strap shoes feature the following:

• A wide strap that fastens across the front of the shoe

• Single or double metal buckles on the strap

Dress boot

A dress boot is similar to an Oxford but with a taller shaft. Dress boots typically feature the following:

• Front laces

• Sleek silhouette

• Elasticized side gusset or zipper

What to look for when buying men’s dress shoes

Toe style

Men’s dress shoes feature a variety of toe styles that each provide a distinctive look.

• Plain: This type of toe offers the simplest, cleanest look with no adornments of any kind.

• Cap: This type of toe features a horizontal stitch across the front part of the shoe to create a cap for the toe.

• Wingtip: This type of toe features a cap in a “W” or “M” shape that gives a wing-like design.

• Split/apron: This type of toe features a stitched seam that runs around the toe.

Material

Most men’s dress shoes are made of leather. However, if you want your shoes to last as long as possible, it’s important to consider the type of leather.

• Full-grain leather: This type of leather isn’t treated much, so its surface, or grain, may contain some flaws or texture. However, it ages very well and often develops an attractive patina over time. Full-grain leather is considered the highest quality, so dress shoes that feature it are usually costly.

• Corrected leather: This type of leather has been sanded to remove surface flaws and texture. An artificial grain is then added and sealed in place to create an attractive, stain-resistant surface. However, corrected leather creases easily and may peel over time. That said, most men’s dress shoes use corrected leather.
   

Most manufacturers clearly identify shoes that are made with full-grain leather. Corrected leather is often referred to as simply “leather.” You can also spot full-grain leather by its deeper, richer color and textured feel. Corrected leather tends to have a smooth feel that’s similar to plastic.

Some men’s dress shoes are made with suede or a combination of leather and suede, though these styles tend to be more business casual than formal. If you’re uncomfortable with animal products, you can also find men’s dress shoes made of high-quality faux leather that looks very similar to the real deal.

Construction

A dress shoe’s construction refers to how its sole is attached to the upper part of the shoe. There are several different construction styles, but the three most commonly used for dress shoes are Goodyear welting, Blake stitch, and cemented.

• Goodyear welting

This is the most labor-intensive type of construction, though it can be done by hand or machine. The sole is stitched to the rest of the shoe for maximum durability and breathability. It also allows for easy resoling if necessary.

• Blake stitch

This type of construction is similar to Goodyear welting, though it results in a simpler style. The shoes can be resoled but require a specific machine. However, shoes with Blake stitching offer increased durability at a more affordable price point.

• Cemented

This type of construction is the most budget-friendly. Instead of stitching the sole onto the rest of the shoe, an adhesive is used, which doesn’t allow for resoling. Dress shoes with this type of construction usually aren’t very durable.

Heel

The heels on men’s dress shoes typically shouldn’t be higher than one inch. If you’re on the shorter side, however, you may prefer a slightly higher heel that measures about one and a half inches.

Color

• Black

Black is the most common color for men’s dress shoes. However, it doesn’t always pair well with navy.

• Brown

Brown is actually a more flexible color choice for dress shoes. For a dressy look, stick to darker brown shades because light brown shades like tan give a more casual appearance.

• Dark red

Dark red shades, such as burgundy, cognac, oxblood, or cordovan, are striking color options for men’s dress shoes, though they aren’t the most versatile.

Embellishments

Men’s dress shoes often feature embellishments to give them a more distinctive appearance.

Brogueing is a series of decorative perforations along a dress shoe’s seams.

Wingtip shoes are an example of full brogueing, while other styles only feature perforations along certain seams.

Tassels can add a sophisticated, classic look to men’s dress shoes. They’re usually found at the front of shoes and are a common feature on loafers.

How much should you pay for men’s dress shoes?

Men’s dress shoes vary in price based on the material, construction, and embellishments, but you can typically expect to spend between $15 and $500.

Budget-friendly

For a pair of men’s dress shoes made of faux leather, you’ll usually pay between $15 and $75.

Mid-range

For a pair of men’s dress shoes made of corrected leather with cemented construction and few embellishments, you’ll usually pay between $60 and $175.

Expensive

For a pair of men’s dress shoes made of high-quality or full-grain leather featuring welted construction and embellishments, you’ll usually pay between $175 and $500.

Tips for long-lasting men’s dress shoes

• Keep your leather dress shoes in excellent condition by cleaning and shining them regularly. This will prevent cracking and fading in the leather.

• If you wear dress shoes to the office every day, you should own several pairs. Even a well-made, durable pair will wear out quickly if worn daily.

• To make sure your dress shoes keep their shape, store them on a cedar shoe tree.

• Your dress shoes will maintain their shape more effectively if you use a shoe horn to put them on, rather than simply shoving your foot inside.

Most men’s dress shoes have leather soles, but some dress shoes have rubber soles, which provide better traction in inclement weather.

FAQ

Q. How should men’s dress shoes fit?

A. Dress shoes should fit well the first time you try them on – don’t expect to break them in over time. You shouldn’t feel the front of the shoe pressing against your toes or bunching in any way. The shoes shouldn’t squeeze against the sides of your foot or slide right or left too much when you walk in them.

Q. What should I look for in a more casual dress shoe?

A. The type of shoe that you choose affects how casual it looks. Loafers and dress boots tend to offer a more relaxed look, so they pair well with chinos and other business casual clothing. It also helps to consider the material and color. Suede shoes give a more casual look, while a lighter color like tan works well for a relaxed, informal look.

Q. How long should men’s dress shoes last?

A. The lifespan of a pair of dress shoes depends on the material and how they’re constructed, as well as how often you wear them. Full-grain leather shoes with welted construction are typically the most durable and can last five years or more, depending on how often you wear them. Lower-quality leather or faux leather shoes with cemented construction typically don’t last longer than a year.