Best Fancy Feast Cat Food

Updated July 2020
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
Why trust BestReviews?
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Read more  
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.Read more 
How we decided

We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

17 Models Considered
68 Hours Researched
1 Experts Interviewed
126 Consumers Consulted
Zero products received from manufacturers.

We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

Buying guide for best Fancy Feast cat food

Last Updated July 2020

From cozy beds to enticing toys, most cat owners can’t resist spoiling their pets. Topping the list of ways to make felines happy is providing food they can’t resist. That’s why Fancy Feast cat food has become a fan favorite among cats and their doting owners. But Fancy Feast has more to offer than feline-pleasing flavor. Cat owners will appreciate the variety and nutritional value as much as their pets love eating this gourmet cat cuisine.

Fancy Feast offers both dry and wet cat food in a variety of cat-approved flavors, recipes, and textures. The brand also makes appetizers, sliced filets, and broth-covered delicacies that can be provided to kitties as treats to complement their usual meals. Kitten varieties are also available, so there is a Fancy Feast food for just about any cat, young or old.

With so many delicious cat food options available, it can be confusing choosing a Fancy Feast variety for your beloved pet. Fortunately, BestReviews is here to sort out your options. Continue reading our buying guide to learn everything you need to know about Fancy Feast cat food, and then check out our favorite varieties when you’re ready to tempt your feline.

Fancy Feast cat food is made by Purina, one of the most popular and trusted pet products companies. It has been producing quality animal food for more than 90 years.

Key considerations

Why Fancy Feast cat food?

If you’re a cat owner, you know that your cat food options seem almost limitless, so deciding on a brand and formula can be daunting. Plus, your cat ultimately has a say in the matter, because if Fluffy won’t eat the food you pick, your search continues. There are many good reasons to choose Fancy Feast cat food for your pet, including flavors that most kitties can’t resist.

Fancy Feast is made by Purina, a trusted brand in the animal feed market. Fancy Feast cat foods are rich in protein and essential vitamins and minerals. There are numerous flavors, recipes, and textures available in the brand’s collection of canned varieties. And with multipacks of canned varieties, your cat can sample different flavors. Many felines that tend to be picky about eating kibble dive right into Fancy Feast’s dry cat foods. And best of all, for a gourmet cat food with enticing taste, Fancy Feast is reasonably priced.

Dry vs. wet cat food

Cats enjoy crunchy food, and they can’t wait to dive into a bowl of fresh wet food. Fancy Feast makes both, and there are pros and cons to each. Here are some factors about both types of cat food to help you decide which is best for your cat.
 

Dry cat food: Dry food has several benefits over wet cat food. 

  • Good for dental health: When cats chew the crunchy pellets, it may help remove tartar buildup that can lead to gum and teeth issues.

  • Easy to store: Dry food can be kept fresh in the bag it arrives in or transferred to a pet food storage bin for easy access. Unused canned food must be kept in the refrigerator after it has been opened. 

  • Better for free-feeding: It’s not a good idea to free-feed with canned food because cats tend to eat it quickly and overindulge.

  • Better if you’re on a budget: Canned food is more expensive than dry, so you’ll save a bit of money if you choose to feed your cat dry food. And if you have multiple cats, the cost can add up quickly if you only feed them canned food. 

 

Wet cat food: Canned food has some benefits over dry food. 

  • Good option for older cats: It’s especially good for those that have difficulty chewing.

  • Provides essential moisture: Cats need a healthy amount of water each day to keep their kidneys functioning properly and maintain hydration. Canned food can contain a high level of water — as much as 78% — which supplements the water a cat drinks on a daily basis.

  • Good for picky eaters: Picky cats may prefer wet food. The moist consistency, rich flavors, and intense aroma of canned food makes it difficult for cats to resist, even those that are typically finicky about what they eat.

Chef-worthy recipes

With chunks of meat, real greens and vegetables, and rich sauce, Fancy Feast Medleys canned cat food is crafted for the most discriminating feline palates. The recipes are inspired by real culinary creations and made to be 100% for cats. Medleys are available in several delicious flavors and come in value-priced multipacks. 

Features

Varieties

As mentioned above, Fancy Feast cat food is available in dry and wet formulas, with some variations to consider in each category.

Dry food: This is available in regular gourmet recipes and Naturals that don’t contain artificial ingredients. 

Canned food: Fancy Feast canned food comes in numerous varieties that include Classic recipes, Medleys with chunks of meat and vegetables, Savory Centers with broth-filled middles, and Naturals without artificial additives. You’ll also find canned food made especially with the dietary needs of kittens in mind. 

Appetizers and filets: These are soft yet chewy and ideal as dry food toppers or occasional treats.

Broths: In addition, Fancy Feast also makes Broths that are a combination of meaty bites and rich juice that are ideal for occasional treats or to top off dry food. 

Textures

It goes without saying that dry cat food is crunchy, but wet varieties by Fancy Feast come in several texture options. 

Paté: This has a soft, almost creamy texture.

Ground: This is similar to paté but a bit more coarse.

Shreds: These are small, thin bits of meat or vegetable pieces that are easy to chew. 

Medleys: These have chunky pieces that make it appear similar to foods people eat.

Broths: These have a liquid consistency with medium-size pieces of meat and vegetables.

Combination: Many Fancy Feast varieties have a combination of paté or ground food mixed with savory gravy. 

Flavors

Fancy Feast cat food has different feline taste preferences covered, too. You’ll find that both dry and canned varieties come in flavors like seafood, tuna, salmon, chicken, trout, shrimp, turkey, garden greens, beef, or a combination of several hearty tastes.  

DID YOU KNOW?

Some wet food varieties and toppers by Fancy Feast contain chunks of fish and even whole shrimp, making them excellent choices for cats that love seafood flavors.

Accessories

A few essential accessories will make your cat’s mealtimes go off without a hitch. 

Bowl: Catit Double Diner Cat Bowl

With dual bowls and a stylish base, the Catit Double Diner is all your cat needs to eat and drink. The removable bowls are dishwasher safe and made of stainless steel that’s durable and resists bacteria buildup. Choose from a pink or white base to match your décor. 

Scoop: Dexas Popware for Pets Collapsible KlipScoop

It’s a scoop for serving dry pet food and a clip for keeping a bag of food fresh, all in one. The KlipScoop has an innovative design that pops open to reveal a measured serving scoop. When collapsed, the clip mechanism fits securely over the dry food bag to lock out air that can result in flavor loss. It’s a unique gadget that can make your cat’s mealtime just a bit easier. 

Food dispenser: Arf Pets Automatic Pet Feeder

If you plan to give your cat dry Fancy Feast food, an automatic pet feeder can take the guesswork out of daily feedings. Simply pour the dry food in the unit, set it to customize your cat’s portions, and it does the work for you. It’s versatile to operate, too, because it runs on batteries or with the included power cord. 

Do you have a finicky cat? Any cat owner who has tried Fancy Feast cat food knows how tempting it is to most felines. That's why the brand's wet or dry formulas are worth trying if your cat isn't easily satisfied by other brands.

Fancy Feast cat food prices

The price you pay for Fancy Feast cat food depends on the type and quantity you choose. Keep in mind that Fancy Feast cat food is often available on sale, so prices will vary. 

Dry: Bags of dry Fancy Feast cat food come in several sizes. Bags that weigh 3 to 3.4 pounds range in price from about $7 to $10; 7-pound bags range from $12 to $16; 12-pound bags range from $15 to $24; 18-pound bags cost about $35 to $38. 

Wet: You’ll find Fancy Feast wet food available in cases of 3-ounce cans. Cases with 12 cans cost between $9 and $12; cases with 24 cans cost $20 to $30; cases with 30 to 45 cans cost from $18 to $35. 

Broths: Broths come in 1.4-ounce pouches. Pouches come in quantities of 12 to 16 for $12 to $18. 

Filets: Packs of 6 to 10 filets cost between $12 and $20.

Appetizers: These tempting toppers come in trays in multipacks of 10 and cost around $8 to $12. 

Made for seafood-loving felines

Most cats can’t resist flavors of the sea, and this pack of canned cat food won’t disappoint. It includes salmon, tuna, and seafood mix flavors in consistencies and textures that tempt cats, including paté, chunks, and flaky pieces. 

Tips

  • Stay consistent. If you’re switching to Fancy Feast cat food and your cat’s diet already consists primarily of canned or dry food, follow through with the same type of food.

  • Don’t give up if your cat doesn’t like the first flavor it tries. Both dry and wet Fancy Feast foods come in different flavors, so it’s easy to offer different varieties until you find one your cat prefers. 

  • Opt for convenience. Not only is dry food less messy to feed than wet food, but it’s also suitable for free-feeding, so your cat can return to the bowl to eat throughout the day. You can always add a bit of Fancy Feast wet food to dry food to keep your cat’s diet interesting. 

  • Treat your cat. In addition to tasty food, Fancy Feast also makes a variety of treats that cats love. Choose from crunchy, chewy, or a combination to reward your furbaby or just because. 

  • Try grain-free food. Some Fancy Feast wet foods and treats don’t include any grains in their ingredients. 

DID YOU KNOW?

Fancy Feast cat foods are 100% nutritionally complete with a healthful balance of vitamins and minerals, so you can feel confident feeding your pet this quality brand.

Other products we considered

Whether your cat picks at meals or quickly devours just about any food you put in the bowl, there’s a Fancy Feast cat food that will make your cat come running every time you tear open a bag or pop the top on a can. Our five top picks are cat tested and approved, but the brand also makes other varieties that cats can’t resist.

The Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Collection is true to its name, as this canned food comes in a variety of flavors that are smothered in savory sauces.

Fancy Feast Gourmet Naturals Dry Food offers delicious taste, contains chicken as the main ingredient, and is made without artificial additives.

Finally, the Fancy Feast Classic Paté has the smooth, traditional consistency many cats love in wet food.

If you prefer cat food that doesn’t contain artificial additives, Fancy Feast Gourmet Naturals are a good option for your pet. They include a nice selection of paté and gravy-covered canned foods and white chicken dry food made without artificial colors, preservatives, or flavors.

FAQ

Q. My cat has a sensitive stomach and is prone to digestive upset when she tries new foods. What are some tips for introducing Fancy Feast cat foods into her diet?
A. Introducing your cat to a new food should be done carefully and slowly. If you feed her dry food, gradually mix a bit of the new Fancy Feast kibble in with her usual brand, increasing the amount over several feedings from about a week to two weeks until she adjusts.

Use the same technique if you feed your cat wet food. However, it’s best to choose a basic recipe like chicken paté that tends to be gentler on sensitive stomachs than a recipe that’s rich in gravy or is made with a lot of extra ingredients like seafood or vegetables. 
 

Q. Can I feed my cat a combination of both dry and canned Fancy Feast cat foods?
A. Certainly. Cats appreciate the variety and are often quite enthusiastic about indulging in a little wet food with their dry kibble. Mix about a spoonful of wet into dry to encourage your cat to eat both.  
 

Q. Is there a particular flavor in Fancy Feast canned foods that cats go for?
A. Not necessarily. Just like humans, each cat has its own preference when it comes to taste. But if you have a cat, chances are you’ve noticed it perk up when you open a can of tuna or cook seafood. Likewise, many cats prefer canned cat food that includes seafood ingredients above other varieties. 

The team that worked on this review
  • Bronwyn
    Bronwyn
    Editor
  • Ciera
    Ciera
    Digital Content Producer
  • Jennifer
    Jennifer
    Writer
  • Steph
    Steph
    Web Producer

BestReviews wants to be better. Please take our 3-minute survey,
and give us feedback about your visit today.

Take Survey