5 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Gels - Mar. 2023

For Well-defined Brows

A top-selling eyebrow gel by Maybelline that offers decent wear, natural color, and notable definition. Even if your brows are light in color, chances are this product will work for you.

Has a contoured brush that grooms and shapes brows, and defines arches. Adds natural color to sparse areas and works well for very pale and gray brows. Blonde shade works well for most blondes. A little goes a long way.

Will leave small clumps if you apply it too thickly, but they can be combed out with a spoolie brush. Product tends to dry up somewhat quickly, but closing the lid tightly will help keep it fresh.

Best Bang for the Buck

NYX Professional Makeup

Tinted Brow Mascara

Natural-looking Results

An affordable brow gel that works surprisingly well for a low-cost brand. Has earned many happy customers for the natural results it delivers at a low price point.

Repeat users brag about the long-wearing formula and natural colors. Gel is easy to apply, and feels lightweight. Fills in sparse brows without looking fake or heavy. Most users say it's easy to find a matching color.

TattooStudio Waterproof Eyebrow Gel Makeup

If you prefer dark or bold brow color, it may not work for you. Some consumers received tubes with gel that was dried up on arrival.

Maybelline

Long-wearing Formula

An excellent choice if you need a brow gel that stays put once dried, and prefer darker shades. However, it may disappoint you if you prefer a soft blonde color.

A long-wearing formula that lives up to its name, and has impressive staying power that lasts as long as two days. Does a great job filling in sparse areas and gives brows a full, defined look. Colors are highly pigmented.

Brow This Way Lightweight Gel

Takes a while to dry. Applicator brush has soft bristles and is messy – blotting it helps, but wastes product. Blonde shade is too dark for many blondes.

Rimmel

Versatile Shades

Worth considering if you are looking for a very inexpensive brow gel. Blonde color is very natural. However, the applicator brush and wear could be better.

Very low price point. Comes in colors that look natural on most wearers. Customers rave about how natural the blonde shade looks, even against pale skin and light hair. Fills in sparse spots.

Brush design makes it awkward to use, and too much product comes out on the brush. Tends to flake off throughout the day.

Ardell

Brow Sculpting Gel

Best for Brow Grooming

A lightweight, versatile eyebrow gel that's best for keeping brows neat and tamed. However, if you need brow color, you'll have to pair it with other brow makeup products.

This clear eyebrow gel is perfect for unruly brows, as it defines them and smooths hairs into place. Can be used with other brow products like powders and pencils that add color. Easy to control and use. Doesn't feel sticky.