Facebook Pixel Code
x
BestReview's Logo
Best For Your Buck Product
Best bang for the buck
Wilton
Check Price
Best Of The Best Product
Best of the best
Yost
Check Price
BestReview's Logo
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
How We Decided
  • 51 Models Considered
  • 6 Hours Spent
  • 1 Experts Interviewed
  • 101 Consumers Consulted
  • Zero products received from manufacturers.

    We purchase every product we review with our own funds — we never accept anything from product manufacturers.

    Shopping Guide for Best Bench Vises

    At first glance a bench vise seems a straightforward item. Basic, robust engineering, with a simple function, and intuitive use. But go shopping for one, and you'll find you have a harder choice than you expected. Size, materials, jaw options, and more. Suddenly, it's not such a simple purchase.

    BestReviews is here to unravel the complexities and help you buy exactly the right tool. We test in our own workshops. We talk to experts. We research customer feedback. We find the comprehensive answers you need. We never accept free samples, so manufacturers can't influence our recommendations. It's important you can trust our results, so we spend our own money, and get the same store-bought products you would.

    After getting to grips with a whole bunch of different vises, the five above are those that came out on top. A brief explanation of their features and benefits accompanies each one. If you’re ready to buy, check out the recommendations in that product matrix.

    For a full breakdown of the components and materials that make a top bench vise, you can read the following report. It provides all the knowledge you need to compare and contrast bench vises on your own.

    Like us on Facebook!
    Check your bench is sturdy enough to support your chosen vise, and the kind of work you intend to do. Reinforce it if necessary.

    Types of Vises

    The tool we're talking about here goes by several names: metalworking vise, engineer’s vise, machinist's vise, mechanic's vise or workshop vise. They all fall under the umbrella of bench vises, so for the sake of simplicity, we'll use that term through the remainder this review.

    There are several other kinds of vise.

    • A woodworker's vise is built into the bench. Jaws are steel or iron, but usually have wooden faces, to prevent marking the workpiece. The front (moving) jaw meets the rear jaw at the same level as the bench top. The mechanism is underneath the bench.

    • A post vise – or blacksmith's vise – is a strange beast. Partly fixed to the bench, like a carpenter's, partly above the bench, like a machinist's, it also has a leg that extends to the floor, so it can support greater weights.

    • There are all kinds of handheld vises. There are machine vises (not to be confused with machinist vises) for use with pillar drills and milling machines.

    • Small, lightweight vises, frequently called jeweler's or watchmaker's vises, are miniature versions of the bench vise, but may be able to clamp at multiple angles. Some have suction bases. Jaws are often plastic or nylon so they don't mark delicate components.

    EXPERT TIP

    Bench vises often arrive coated in protective grease. Clean it off with warm water and detergent, or spirit alcohol.


    Staff  | BestReviews

    Bench Vise Construction

    All metalworking vises are of a similar construction. The rear jaw of the vise is part of the base. It has two, three or four bolt holes to fix it to the bench. The rear jaw does not move forward or backward, but the whole assembly may rotate. An anvil area is often incorporated.

    The front jaw is fixed to a slide (sometimes called a beam), which is normally of square section, but with the bottom missing – like an upside-down “U.” Concealed within this slide is a long, heavy-duty, threaded bar. A winding handle is attached, in front of the jaw. Rotation of the handle moves this jaw, closing or opening the vise. Occasionally the beam is a round tube, with the threaded bar inside, though this is not common.

    FOR YOUR SAFETY

    Even a relatively cheap bench vise is a heavy object — thirty pounds is common. A big, heavy-duty model could be twice that. Be careful when you lift it, and when you fix it to your bench. It's a good idea to have someone to lend a hand.

    Bench Vise Materials

    A bench vise has to exert considerable grip and, because it performs numerous tasks, it usually takes quite a pounding. Though you shouldn't strike the vise itself with a hammer, it often happens.

    So it needs to be tough. Low-cost bench vises often use steel, which is light and cheap. It's fine for light duties and for hobbyists, but it doesn't have the high resilience a professional would need.

    The best bench vises are made of cast iron, and two variants can be found: gray iron and ductile iron.

    Gray iron isn't about color, it's used to indicate the presence of graphite flakes. It's the most common form of cast iron, used in everything from vises to stove tops. It's highly resistant to wear, doesn't rust easily, and isn't affected much by heat. Its only drawback is a lower structural strength than ductile iron. It doesn't take impact well, and in extreme cases can fracture.

    For this reason, anvil sections on this kind of vise are often made of a steel plate, welded on. Steel will absorb impact – hammer blows, for example – without cracking, though it is possible to dent it.

    Ductile iron also contains graphite, but the particles are round. This gives it considerable extra strength and high ductility – hence the name. As a result, ductile iron is resistant to cracking, and anvil sections can therefore be made from the same material as the main body.

    EXPERT TIP

    Only use the anvil portion of a vise for hammering. Using the jaws or slide can cause cracks and might eventually break the casting.


    Staff  | BestReviews

    Bench Vise Jaws

    Except in the very cheapest bench vises, jaws are removable. They come in many different shapes, sizes and materials.

    • Serrated jaws give good grip, but can mark surfaces.

    • Nylon jaws are less likely to mark delicate or polished surfaces.

    • Pipe jaws have a V-shaped indent, to grip round tubes or bars.

    • Engineers may make their own jaws, to suit specific tasks.

    Jaw covers are also available. These can be wooden, plastic, or nylon. They simply slip over the existing jaws for different gripping applications. As with replaceable jaws, engineers often make their own.

    DID YOU KNOW?

    A bench vise will, of course, hold things far bigger than the width of the jaws, or the depth of the throat, but working too far from the main area of grip can cause flexing, which often leads to mistakes.

    Bench Vise Capacities

    Bench vises can hold all objects of all shapes and sizes, but there are some restrictions:

    1. The width of the jaws.

    2. How far the jaws can open.

    3. The distance between the top of the jaws and the slide. This is referred to as the throat depth.

    Jaws start from just two inches wide, but four inches is common for an entry-level bench vise. It's a good size for a hobbyist's tool. Sizes increase by half-inch, or one-inch increments, depending on manufacturer. Six inch jaws are probably all most home engineers will need, though eight inch jaws are widely available.

    Jaw openings vary enormously. Mostly, they depend on the length of the slide. This can be a major restriction on the size of item you can hold, so it's important to get it right. Some DIY bench vises only allow an opening of four inches. Professional-grade tools with reversible heads can open as wide as eleven inches.

    Because of the way a bench vise is constructed, throat depth varies little. Even a cheap bench vise will have a throat depth of between two and a half or three inches, yet only a few top-quality models exceed four inches.

    You might see a psi rating on a vise (pounds per square inch). It's the pressure used when casting, and indicates the type of iron. 30,000 psi is gray cast iron, 60,000 psi is ductile cast iron. Some steels can also have high numbers, indicating they are malleable, though not necessarily durable.

    Staff
    BestReviews

    Bench Vise Features

    Though a bench vise is an uncomplicated device, there are a few features that make life easier.

    Many bench vises have a quick-release feature. A finger operated lever, attached below the front jaw, releases the screw thread. This allows the jaw to slide back and forward freely, and therefore more quickly. Releasing the lever re-engages the thread. The vise can't be fully tightened until this is done.

    Swivel bases are common, and a useful addition. It makes it easier to position different parts of the workpiece in front of you, rather than having to move the piece itself. Beware, however, while some rotate through 360°, others may offer considerably less movement.

    A few vises have rotating heads that can carry two sets of jaws. This gives fast access to the second set, saving you the time it would take to change jaws completely.

    CAUTION

    Always check that your vise is securely bolted to the bench. There's danger of a serious accident if it comes loose.

    Safety Tips

    • Never wind the front jaw/slide all the way out. They can be very heavy. If they become detached they can fall and cause injury. They can also be extremely difficult to re-align.

    • Never leave a vise closed when not in use. Doing so causes stress that can lead to fractures.

    • Never use extension bars on the handle. The supplied handle will apply the maximum pressure intended. Trying to exert more can potentially damage the vise, or cause injury to the user.

    • When you've finished work for the day, open the vise jaws slightly and leave the handle in the vertical position. If you leave it horizontal, it can catch you at hip height when you pass, leaving a surprisingly painful bruise.

    Whenever possible, position your item such that the working area is close to the jaws of the vise. This reduces flexing or vibration, and gives you greater control.

    What Does a Good Bench Vise Cost?

    There are some very cheap bench vises around, but bear in mind that these tools exert a tremendous amount of pressure. Metal fatigue and stress fractures are common with poorly cast models.

    You can get get a perfectly good four inch to six inch vise for between $50 and $100. Not a lot of money for a tool you'll probably never wear out.

    If you need greater capacity, or want to invest in something that will take a lot of punishment, top brand bench vises run from around $150 to $250.

    • Bob
      Bob
      Writer
    • Devangana
      Devangana
      Web Producer
    • Eliza
      Eliza
      Digital Content Strategist
    • Jeff
      Jeff
      Editor
    • Jennifer
      Jennifer
      Writer
    • Melissa
      Melissa
      Senior Editor
    ×

    Support Us

    At BestReviews, we purchase every product we review with our own funds. We never accept anything from product manufacturers. Our goal is to be 100% objective in our analysis, and we do not want to run the risk of being swayed by products provided at no cost.

    Help support our research and testing by making a contribution.

    $15
    $25
    $50
    $100
    $